Thinking about it, it sounds vaguely like the "Market for Lemons" (information asymmetry) problem: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Market_for_Lemons
In that there are some people doing good things there, some people selling snake oil, and a lot of doubts in between, it would certainly cause firms to invest less due to doubts that they'd be getting anything worthwhile.
Perhaps. It's just off the top of my head.
But seriously it would be better if you spend the time optimizing for humans, rather than playing with Googles algorithms.
Step 1. Find what people are searching for.
Step 2. Provide content that meets their search criteria.
Result: You have optimized for humans.
Obviously there are other ways of optimizing for humans. Some of those ways might even bring greater returns. But you don't necessarily have to choose between SEO and those other ways. The optimum strategy is usually to pursue both when possible.