Re:On Minimalism
by revorad on Monday August 29, 2011 @05:04AM
(#2936493)
When I read posts like these, I can't help but wonder if minimalistic people go around feeling smug and superior all the time. If you think and talk a lot about how great your minimalistic life is, then you're probably suffering from what some call spiritual materialism.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
People who do something that changes their lives for the better usually enjoy letting other people know how they can try to do the same thing. It's exciting for the person who succeeded, so they want to show others "the way." It may come off as elitist, but I think it's just excitement.
>I can't help but wonder if minimalistic people go around feeling smug and superior all the time.
Selection bias rears its ugly head again -- you never read blog posts by minimalists who don't write blog posts about their lives.
reminiscent of: http://www.theonion.com/articles/area-man-constantly-mention...
Re:On Minimalism
by chriseidhof on Monday August 29, 2011 @05:31AM
(#2936551)
Haha, nice :D. I watch TV shows though.
BTW, I don't even own a television!
There is an alternative explanation for the pro-minimalistic posts: maybe reducing your stuff actually has the benefits the posts speak about? In this case it would be natural to share it so that other people can benefit too.
That's true, hence the probabilistic tone in my comment. I know from personal experience that reducing stuff can simplify your life and make you feel better. But so can having more stuff, just like the author found by getting a Kindle!
I think that's an important point.
Was replacing his book collection with a Kindle an example of "less stuff" or "more stuff"? I don't think it's either. It's an alternative, and in this case, it felt like "less stuff" to him. That was in line with his goal and it worked.
Re:On Minimalism
by chriseidhof on Monday August 29, 2011 @05:09AM
(#2936514)
No, I don't. I've accepted that people are really different. Another minimalist/buddhist thing I try to do is not to judge other people, but just try to understand them and feel compassion.
That's great. My comment above was not directed specifically at your post, but more generally because I've read a lot of similar posts.
I find not judging people almost impossible. Isn't judging people, things and events what makes me an intelligent creature? What do you (or Buddhists) think of accepting oneself as a judgmental person?
Re:On Minimalism
by chriseidhof on Monday August 29, 2011 @05:19AM
(#2936529)
It is extremely hard. I am very bad at it. However, once you get better at it you'll notice how you can accept people for who they are. This then helps understanding them, and (almost?) everybody has an interesting story to tell, which you wouldn't have heard otherwise.