Maybe it is the lightest tent when considering the weather it can deal with, but this was not mentioned in your original message.
I don't get the analogy with the Tesla going to space? You don't expect cars to fly. What would be the tent equivalent? Using the tent as a boat?
I hike inside and around the arctic circle, sometimes during winter time.
That my shelter, that can take the beating that this kind of climate can dish out, weighs only around 1/30th of my total equipment weight makes it an incredible deal.
And subjectively very light.
I have hiked above the arctic circle but not during winter time. Then I would look towards what you are using. ;) You do seem to hike a little heavier than me, but that could be a seasonal thing. When I go for a 10 day summer trip my pack is around 19-23kg, enough stuff to deal with weather around 0C and rain storms.
Given that I've been in it during weather reaching up to 35 on the Beaufort scale (~20m/s) with severe rain I feel it packs a fantastic punch for its weight.
I'm sure there are some niche ultra light space age material tents out there.
But that would be like saying a Tesla isn't a good car because it can't reach space.