News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Impact of Vitamin D Level on Covid-19: Systematic Rev... by gameswithgo on Friday November 26, 2021 @12:01PM (#29351913)
Vaccines are probably 3 orders of magnitude more effective at reducing the spread of covid than vitamin d. Not 3 times, 3 orders of magnitude, probably more than that really. Imperfect as they are it is still an amazing and wonderful thing we were able to create and get them out so quickly, likely millions of lives saved and millions more would have been if not for morons spreading lies
Re:The Impact of Vitamin D Level on Covid-19: Systematic Rev... by ravenstine on Friday November 26, 2021 @12:08PM (#29351969)
For sure, I don't deny that at all.

My point is that these things are reflections of society (civilization?) as a whole. If society is being fractionated, you'll see it with vitamins and vaccines. From what I've seen, few things haven't seen some amount of fractionation for my whole life.

It doesn't really matter whether or not any of this stuff works if the establishment isn't widely considered to be legitimate. You will inevitably end up with two camps, or possibly an entire loss of control. The point of actually doing things to instill confidence is to give few to no reasons for society to fractionate down the middle.

Like, if you want people to take vaccination seriously, you probably don't want to tell the public you won't take the vaccine because you don't like the current president. You also probably want to level with them and at least tell them some of the truth as opposed to using omission and indirection, and no coercion, to get them to do what you want them to do. Oh, and it would also be a good idea to not villainize skeptics, because there will always be people who are wrong, instead favoring giving them reason to come to your side.

All of the above that I just mentioned happened, at least in the United States. It's not hard to find sound-bites of establishment top-brass saying that they wouldn't take the vaccines because they didn't trust Trump. When people on both sides see this indignance and then see these politicians make a complete 180 once they've restored their power, why in the hell would you expect anyone to trust them with their health? A skeptical person is going to start wondering what else those politicians have lied about and why the establishment health experts haven't told people to improve their health as part of the fight against the pandemic. If mainstream news comes out trying to downplay Vitamin D, they might think "heck, if they're saying that then I should probably believe the opposite".

I'm sure I'll be misunderstood by what I've said there, but hopefully someone reads this and considers it if they haven't before. I've never been anti-vaccine, and if I ever said anything in the past that came off that way, either I misspoke or I was wrong.

Re:The Impact of Vitamin D Level on Covid-19: Systematic Rev... by watwut on Friday November 26, 2021 @01:38PM (#29352782)
I like how the you manage to blame primary pro-vaccine people for not promoting them perfectly for vaccine skepticism ... while completely ignoring pure FUD and lies routinely used by anti-vaccine movements.

And how it is only democrats who are responsible for some anti-vaccine claims despite massive anti-vaccine, anti-masks campaigns from republican politicians.

Re:The Impact of Vitamin D Level on Covid-19: Systematic Rev... by ravenstine on Friday November 26, 2021 @03:26PM (#29353759)
I could have addressed that side as well, but I didn't think it was necessarily relevant to the point. There's also now diverging definitions of what defines "anti-vaxx". Anti-vaxxers might be against all vaccines, or anti-vaxx might mean being against the mRNA vaccines for SARS-CoV2, and then sometimes I get labeled as such (or as a sympathizer) because I think there are valid concerns about these vaccines.

In terms of the OG anti-vaxxers, I agree that they did and perhaps do still play a significant role in fostering distrust. In my opinion, that's just too easy a point to make. Did I really need to make a point about it? It's not really a controversial opinion to state on HN that people who are out of touch with reality share responsibility for vaccine hesitancy.

What's more important is that we recognize that this issue doesn't exist in isolation. I do not buy that the extreme anti-vaxxers share the bulk of responsibility here. The authorities had a chance to get everyone on board, and they totally blew it. Anti-vaxxers could have not existed before this pandemic and they would have still been created as a part of the radical shifts in global societies and how power structures have used tactics that appear to rather intentionally create divisions.

> And how it is only democrats who are responsible for some anti-vaccine claims despite massive anti-vaccine, anti-masks campaigns from republican politicians.

Yes, that is true, and I corrected myself before I even saw your comment.

Re:The Impact of Vitamin D Level on Covid-19: Systematic Rev... by watwut on Saturday November 27, 2021 @07:31AM (#29359674)
You framed or as whole society explanation of universal sociological truth of things splitting to two sides down inthe middle.

And in subsequent analysis you completely ignore active and large campaigns to make people distrust vaccines or that covid exists.

> The point of actually doing things to instill confidence is to give few to no reasons for society to fractionate down the middle.

The expectation is that group you dislike for unrelated reasons have to be perfect. The group you like for unrelated reasons is not responsible for anything they say or do.

> do not buy that the extreme anti-vaxxers share the bulk of responsibility here

People believing anti-vaxxers are responsibility of loud anti-vaxxers. There was no magic happening, it was people believing what those said.

> The authorities had a chance to get everyone on board, and they totally blew it.

Large political movements were anti vaccers for political reasons. There was no chance to get everyone on board, when actual politicians and party operatives actively openly and frequently opposed vaccines.

And your analysis completely misses these people.

Re:The Impact of Vitamin D Level on Covid-19: Systematic Rev... by brianwawok on Friday November 26, 2021 @12:23PM (#29352096)
Right, and of course - why not both? Low vitamin D causes other problems, easy to happen in the cold months…
Re:The Impact of Vitamin D Level on Covid-19: Systematic Rev... by ravenstine on Friday November 26, 2021 @01:36PM (#29352757)
My stance might be very different if the state and the mainstream decided to encourage the public to not only get vaccinated but also do things to be healthy. Losing weight, restricting calories, choosing to eat lentils instead of Macaroni and Cheese, going on daily/nightly walks, getting sun exposure, all shouldn't be ignored or treated as obsolete. What exactly is the reason, other than keeping the junk food industry afloat, that we not all be encouraging ourselves? Do we really need a bunch of studies to be performed to conclude that being generally healthy is either helpful against infection or at least won't make infection worse?

If we had a campaign of "do your part, eat right, get some walking in, and help the fight against COVID", I'd be like "Hell yeah! Now's our chance to see if we can beat this thing! Get the vaccines, get healthy, and join the fight!"

And now look. :(

https://www.cnbc.com/2021/04/09/fitness-companies-surge-in-d...

I've come across some data supposedly contesting the idea that obesity is a big driver in hospitalizations, but I'm not sure how much I buy it yet, and it certainly doesn't seem like a good reason to just do nothing at all.

Re:The Impact of Vitamin D Level on Covid-19: Systematic Rev... by GekkePrutser on Friday November 26, 2021 @09:58PM (#29356901)
Personally all the covid restrictions make me so depressed that I don't care about my health. And I never really cared enough about it to lose weight anyway. I was very active before the masks came in (hiking etc) but they enforced them even outdoor when on your own. So the sudden stop in doing that didn't work out well. But generally I just eat wrong, I live alone and hate cooking. So I've always been on the heavier end of the range.

The way life is right now I wouldn't really have any interest in reaching my pension age anyway as there's not much to do.

But promoting this in a situation where people have less motivation is not really going to help. Once the pandemic is over and we can live life again I'll think about it.

But depression factors into it majorly for me and I've been more depressed than ever.

Re:The Impact of Vitamin D Level on Covid-19: Systematic Rev... by kevin_thibedeau on Friday November 26, 2021 @02:08PM (#29353061)
It isn't the government's job to endorse someone's regimen of virtue.
Re:The Impact of Vitamin D Level on Covid-19: Systematic Rev... by datameta on Friday November 26, 2021 @03:26PM (#29353756)
It depends on if you think the government exists for the betterment of society as a whole or for the betterment of the individual.
Re:The Impact of Vitamin D Level on Covid-19: Systematic Rev... by dls2016 on Friday November 26, 2021 @03:15PM (#29353656)
Yet we tax vices.
Re:The Impact of Vitamin D Level on Covid-19: Systematic Rev... by pdonis on Friday November 26, 2021 @01:48PM (#29352876)
What are you basing your numbers on?
[dead]
Re:The Impact of Vitamin D Level on Covid-19: Systematic Rev... by msrenee on Friday November 26, 2021 @12:39PM (#29352224)
You mind linking a source for that statement?
Re:The Impact of Vitamin D Level on Covid-19: Systematic Rev... by beagle3 on Friday November 26, 2021 @12:54PM (#29352374)
I am on phone now and can’t search, but: the original Pfizer report at 6 months listed 15:14 vaccine:placebo deaths (of which 1:2 were attributed to covid). It was updated on the FDA website to say 21:17 (still 1:2 Covid) which is surprising, because the data collection supposedly stopped 2 months before the original publication date.

Regardless, the only double blind RCT ever for the Pfizer vaccine found 2 Covid related deaths in the placebo arm, and 1 in the vaccine arm - over 22,000 participants each. Make of it why you will.

Additionally, the all cause mortality of the vaccine arm is 24% higher than the placebo arm. Again, make of that what you will.

Re:The Impact of Vitamin D Level on Covid-19: Systematic Rev... by msrenee on Sunday November 28, 2021 @09:47AM (#29369296)
I think I found the study that the website you got this info from is referencing. The 2 deaths in the control group and the 1 in the vaccine group don't appear to be attributed to covid. Honestly I can't find anywhere that says what they died from, which isn't unusual when explaining why participants did not complete a study. The researchers don't necessarily have access to that information and rely on what is reported to them.

I'm not sure what you're trying to explain to me in your first paragraph.

Edit:

"Two BNT162b2 recipients died (one from arteriosclerosis, one from cardiac arrest), as did four placebo recipients (two from unknown causes, one from hemorrhagic stroke, and one from myocardial infarction). No deaths were considered by the investigators to be related to the vaccine or placebo. No Covid-19–associated deaths were observed. "

It looks like pretty normal random chance and more people from the placebo group died anyway.

Re:The Impact of Vitamin D Level on Covid-19: Systematic Rev... by beagle3 on Sunday November 28, 2021 @05:11PM (#29373576)
See the material in https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29373534

All cause mortality: 21 died in vaccine arm, 17 in placebo arm.

You may argue the numbers are very small, but (a) that's not trivial to state; (b) there is no evidence the pfizer vaccine reduces all cause mortality in a controlled trial - on the contrary, and (c) one may disregard all cause mortality and only care about corona mortality, but in that case (c1) the numbers are too small (1:2) and easily proven to be meaningless, and (c2) it's a bad metric, since -- taken ad absurdum -- a cyanide shot achieves 100% reduction in corona death.

Re:The Impact of Vitamin D Level on Covid-19: Systematic Rev... by beagle3 on Sunday November 28, 2021 @02:00PM (#29371753)
I was referring to a document on the fda website. I’ll find it later when on desktop.
Re:The Impact of Vitamin D Level on Covid-19: Systematic Rev... by msrenee on Sunday November 28, 2021 @09:31AM (#29369163)
If you could get me the sources you're drawing these conclusions from. Your summary isn't exactly helpful.
Re:The Impact of Vitamin D Level on Covid-19: Systematic Rev... by beagle3 on Sunday November 28, 2021 @05:07PM (#29373534)
See 2nd paragraph of pg. 23 of https://www.fda.gov/media/151733/download for the 21:17 numbers. I can't find the death breakdown for this right now (perhaps it's in this doc, but a quick scan didn't see it), but you can see the previous revision on https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2021.07.28.21261159v... - following the supplemental material link to https://www.medrxiv.org/content/medrxiv/early/2021/07/28/202... , Table S4 on page 12 gives a cause-of-death breakdown.
Re:The Impact of Vitamin D Level on Covid-19: Systematic Rev... by msrenee on Sunday November 28, 2021 @07:03PM (#29374671)
Oh, good, it looks like the vaccine also prevents myocardial infarction, multiple organ disfunction syndrome, and overdose. Better be careful though, it appears to cause lung cancer and arteriosclerosis.

Or there's not much here that's statistically significant and out of 44k people, some of them are going to die from unrelated factors over the course of 6 months.

How can you look at a table that includes sepsis, septic shock, and Shigella infection out of 29 deaths and assume the difference of either 1 or 4 deaths is anything more than noise? It might be worth running the numbers and seeing if it might possibly maybe be statistically significant, but to decide that there being 1 or 4 more deaths in the vaccine group means the vaccine is dangerous in some unknown way is just a misunderstanding of statistics. I mean 2 myocardial infarctions in the placebo and none in the vaccine group? We all better get our vaccines before we have heart attacks.

Re:The Impact of Vitamin D Level on Covid-19: Systematic Rev... by beagle3 on Monday November 29, 2021 @02:46AM (#29377382)
First, you can make of that what you want, but the bottom line is that acm is increased. Is that statistically significant? Depends on your priors, but the answer is likely “no”.

The plague of the century requires vaccine mandates and firing people - when vaccination doesn’t actually reduce acm. Is this statement wrong?

But, you know, we vaccinate to combat severe disease, right? That EUA was given for …. 4 cases in the placebo arm vs 1 in the vaccine arm for “fully vaccinated”. Yes, we jabbed the entire planet for 1:4 out of 22K:22k of severe covid in the RCT. (The famous 95% proclamation was for symptoms that amounted to the common cold).

As someone who has been following the actual data, rather than the headlines, everything looks incredibly crazy. The world has killed its economy and mandated experimental jabs when the only real trial showed no statistically significant effect against severe disease, and the final report shows no effect on all cause mortality (perhaps a deterioration, certainly not an improvement).

There will be no further reports, because the control group was eliminated the day after the end of the 6 months trial.

I find this weird and crazy, with no explanation so far (I am ignoring conspiracies). Ymmv.

P.s. you must look closely at acm, including things like septic shock. Humanity has no experience with mRNA technology that can just assume it has no problems other than those you predicted; the list of known adverse events is constantly being enlarged.

Re:The Impact of Vitamin D Level on Covid-19: Systematic Rev... by msrenee on Monday November 29, 2021 @06:44PM (#29386893)
Mortality isn't the only important measure here. A big argument that's been made for the vaccine is that it reduces the likelihood of hospitalization. This study doesn't specifically go into hospitalizations, but out of 31 severe cases of Covid-19, 30 of them were in the placebo group. It's important to note that there were only 31 severe cases of Covid-19. It's not surprising that the mortality rate between the placebo and vaccine groups is pretty even with those numbers.

I'm glad that you're trying to follow the data and not just the headlines, but it's also important to have the base knowledge to understand what the data actually indicates.