I think you would be hard pressed to find someone who honestly believes a Thinkpad to be more elegant than a Macbook Air.
A response of, "Disregard that the design sucks cocks,"
Excuse me?
The x220 certainly ain't ugly - it is thin, lightweight and durable. Many prefer the Thinkpad design. So even if for you personally elegance may be the first/only priority without override - many people are not that obsessive when it comes to choosing a work laptop.
So the X220 is certainly a choice when you are thinking Macbook Air. The screen size falls nicely between the too small 11" and a bit too big 13.3", the CPUs are same gen, SSD is configurable etc.
Okay, I'm genuinely curious here. What's with all the strange, reactionary posts in this thread, and mis-categorization of people? When did I say anything about elegance being my first priority? I was quite clear in my statement, yet you've skewed it in a bizarre manner.
many people are not that obsessive when it comes to choosing a work laptop
Obsessive? How about appreciative? In fact, how about any word which isn't loaded? Again, there is some strange, defensive stuff going on here.
> > A response of, "Disregard that the design sucks cocks,"
>
> Excuse me?
Sorry, my (previous) 4chan roots showing through:http://knowyourmeme.com/memes/disregard-that-i-suck-cocks#.T...
My point was that the responder at the top of the thread was saying (in so many words):
ignore all of that so-called 'content' in the parent
post, my (subjective) ideas about the design should
trump all of thatAs for your summary, I find it to be amazingly slanted toward a particular view. The X220 is truly nothing at all like the Macbook Air. I used a consumer grade Toshiba, so I have no horse in this race, but I can plainly see (from specs as well as design) that the X220 is in a significantly different category from the Air.
The elegance of the design alone is not enough to place it in a different category. If the argument had been that it can't be classified in the same category as the MacBook Air (with a list of reasons other than "I think that it looks ugly"), then this thread would look a lot different.
The original post suggesting the X220 listed a bunch of specs that it had (and that the poster needed) that the MacBook Air didn't. A response of, "Disregard that the design sucks cocks," adds nothing to the discussion even if that it your personal opinion. If someone thinks that the external looks of the laptop are important, they are not going to just blindly make the purchase based a comment on HN without personally checking it out.
The more important discussions are things like:
* X is billed as (or looks to be in the surface) a replacement for Y, but once you get it out of the showroom you'll notice issues A, B and C.
* X looks really cheap on the surface, but in my experience it's extremely durable.
* X looks really good, but doesn't run Operating System Y.
* X looks like it runs Operating System Y, until you need to use feature/hardware component Z.