everyone falls prey to wishful thinking
To be fair, nobody has ever designed a CPU based on current process technologies. Design teams are always saying "we think the process technology we'll end up working with will look something like this...", and based on past history there was no reason to think that the power issue wouldn't get solved like it had the past N times.
I'm certainly not claiming I could have done better. But the Pentium 4 was such a spectacular failure and Intel's competition managed to navigate that transition well enough that I feel a certain amount of pointing and laughing is justified. :)
> Pentium 4 was absolutely the right design to take advantage of faster transistors
No, it was a horrible design in many ways, irrespective of those constraints and any wishful thinking about the power wall, and it gave the advantage to AMD for years. Not a big surprise as it was designed by Intel's B team. The Pentium M which has been the microarchitectural basis for their subsequent desktop processors was designed by the A team.