The comment above says I would just do X, and bringing up RaTG13 and BANAL-52 as an argument as if it's all trivial. They share 96.2% and 96.9% similarity with sars-cov-2. There are seemingly unrelated animals sharing that much. The linked study also doesn't mention any of that.
I'm not going to argue one way or the other, but I'm starting to get really annoyed at people posting random studies they half understand to argue one way or the other. Covid-19 discussions hackernews(or reddit for that matter) are like the Joe Rogan of nerds. It's ridiculous, people here should know or act better.
Also, nobody reasonable is arguing that BANAL-52 is not evolutionarily related to SARS-CoV2. Of course it is. But that could be true even if it were a precursor of some virus that was later engineered in a lab.
To fully convince me of a natural origin hypothesis, you'd have to find a virus in an animal reservoir that had a highly similar RBD with a furin cleavage site -- or something within a few point mutations of a furin cleavage site. Also, a high degree of homology across the remainder of the genome.
The earliest case identified in the market was on December 11. There's simply no way that was the first actual case.
https://twitter.com/BallouxFrancois/status/14621732432474071...
Wait that never happens...
https://www.reddit.com/r/China_Flu/comments/es21aq/wuhan_pne...
(Chinese original has been deleted, but I remember seeing it at the time and running it through google, scroll down for English translation in the comments)
which reports a case with symptoms starting 24th December, and reports of the hospitals in Wuhan already having multiple cases. Patient didn't visit the market, but did work near.
With what we now know of disease progression, and infectiousness, this pushes the initial date back at least a month, probably two or more.