News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Rational Home Buying by mkramlich on Saturday August 27, 2011 @03:07PM (#2932163)
I also like to inject into any discusion of home buying the point that nobody truly buys a home, it's just a different variant on renting and serfdom to the state. When I own a ball, it's mine, and absent me using it to hurt someone with it, it will not and cannot legally be taken away from me. Additionally, since I own the ball, and am not merely renting the ball, I do not have to make any monthly or yearly payments to any other party in order to keep ownership and possession of the ball. Where when you "buy" and "own" a home (assuming current US, etc), you are required in 99.99% of typical situations to pay taxes at periodic intervals. If you do not, eventually men with guns will come use violence if necessary to force you out of that home and take "ownership" away from you. If you squint your eyes a bit that should look like renting. Rather, the government entities which claim dominance over the area containing your home have a set of rules which allows you to acquire the illusion of ownership over a home in exchange for paying rent/tax to that government periodically. Whether you call that money transfer rent or tax does not matter as much as the physical event that occurs and it's net effects and consequences.

Now I understand there are some ownership qualities to so-called home ownership, not denying that. There are shades of gray between pure renting and pure owning. But what most people talk about is something clearly in the middle of that spectrum, not on one end. Thus, I think the better description is different variants on renting. Different lease permutations.

Re:Rational Home Buying by forkandwait on Saturday August 27, 2011 @11:28PM (#2933199)
While some of my best friends are libertarians ... they tend to oversimplify very complex dynamics that aren't really understood by anybody -- not Bernanke, Marx, Milton, or Keynes, much less Ayn Rand.

Flip comments aside: "ownership" of anything -- a ball, a company, a piece of property -- should be seen as a bundle of rights and responsibilities, and as a (overall) benign socially sanctioned fiction like streetlights. Then you can see that it is only in the trivial cases, like a ball that nobody cares about, that ownership is straightforward and implies "It's mine I can do anything with it I like".

So, duh, you pay taxes and have to conform to zoning codes. Get over it.

EDIT: Also, "government entities" aren't some weird uncontrollable force like the weather or an invading army -- you live in a democracy, so get involved.

Re:Rational Home Buying by forkandwait on Sunday August 28, 2011 @01:32PM (#2934417)
Just noticed that I cited "streetlights" as a social fiction -- I meant "traffic rules".
Re:Rational Home Buying by specialist on Sunday August 28, 2011 @10:37AM (#2933989)
Love it. Both the analysis and "get involved" concluding advice.
Re:Rational Home Buying by onedognight on Saturday August 27, 2011 @09:33PM (#2933036)
As you said, you not allowed to just sit on the land and not provide a good to the rest of the country (in one way or another). As much as I empathize with your reaction, it seems to me that the use it or lose it philosophy brought on by the property tax policy is actually an efficient way to allocate land in a country.
Re:Rational Home Buying by jamesaguilar on Saturday August 27, 2011 @03:14PM (#2932192)
In this sense, all work is slavery since you can't take home all you earn. It is good libertarian hyperbolic, but probably not a useful comment in this context.
Re:Rational Home Buying by georgieporgie on Saturday August 27, 2011 @03:18PM (#2932208)
Since I don't like to downvote without replying, here you go:

If you don't want to support existing infrastructure, I suggest that you become very wealthy, buy an island, and live there by yourself.

The difference between buying and renting is enormously larger than the difference between buying and your theoretical-complete-ownership-of-land. Additionally, in your theoretical ownership world, you would have zero infrastructure to support you and, indeed, would never have had the economic engine to build your wealth in the first place.

Re:Rational Home Buying by JeffL on Saturday August 27, 2011 @04:04PM (#2932313)
To be fair, infrastructure could be paid for entirely by use taxes and not by general taxation.

Water, electricity, and gas infrastructure can be paid for by taxes on those services, and people who don't want them can not purchase water, electricity, or gas from the "grid". Roads can be paid for with gas taxes, and that way are paid for proportionally by those who use them.

And to add to the GP's post, government can choose to seize your land at any time using eminent domain laws are are more and more abused every day. So, whether or not you agree with Libertarianism, I do think he has a point that there are a lot of similarities between buying and renting that a lot of people maybe don't realize.

I think that the choice of paying property tax and living on an island is a false dichotomy. We could theoretically live in a society without paying property tax, where the government can't seize your land.

Re:Rational Home Buying by ericd on Saturday August 27, 2011 @11:42PM (#2933218)
How would the govt. make infrastructure improvements like high speed trains if it couldn't use eminent domain, though? It's an intractable problem to negotiate with everyone along a path simultaneously, and if they hit a block of people unwilling to sell, and the train couldn't be made to turn fast enough to avoid it at speed, you'd either have a very slow train, or they'd have to waste another x months negotiating a different path. We trade absolute liberty for pragmatism.
Re:Rational Home Buying by mturmon on Sunday August 28, 2011 @04:02AM (#2933568)
I tire of catch phrases like "...eventually men with guns will come use violence if necessary to force you out of that home...." Pointless hyperbole.
Re:Rational Home Buying by Symmetry on Sunday August 28, 2011 @11:43AM (#2934123)
I don't think its pointless. I'm all for taxation, but we should do well to remember that all power comes out of the barrel of a gun, and to be aware of the consequences of how we vote and so be corresponding humble with our power.
Re:Rational Home Buying by mturmon on Sunday August 28, 2011 @02:54PM (#2934630)
There are a lot of problems with the catchphrase. Too many to unpack.

One of them is that this "men with guns" phrase is often deployed to plant some kind of "government over-reach" meme around the most trivial of adult transactions, like paying parking fines and property taxes.

It betrays a childish political naivete. The reason I say it's childish is that it's egocentric, as if the concerns of the speaker (to park where they want, to own large plots of land, that abut other people's land, without any consequence or restraint) were the only ones in existence.

That house is served by roads, protected by police and fire services, and must be in compliance with various perfectly reasonable regulations (like brush clearance). That costs money.

And last, you know where your phrase, "All power comes from the barrel of a gun", comes from, right? Good old chairman Mao, one of the top guys in the 20th century rogues gallery. In a democracy, with functioning courts, this saying is more hyperbole.

I think a more relevant notion is that the state is the entity that has a monopoly on violence (due to Max Weber, see http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monopoly_on_violence).

Re:Rational Home Buying by georgieporgie on Sunday August 28, 2011 @03:07PM (#2934656)
remember that all power comes out of the barrel of a gun

That's a ridiculous simplification. You may as well say, "all power comes from tanks," or, "all power comes from nuclear arms."

If the county takes your house, the sheriff will come out to escort you off the property. Guns don't come into play unless you pose a threat to their lives. Even if guns do come into play, that's still not ultimately the force that moves you. Being outnumbered by a better organized group is what ultimately forces you out. The guns are just one small part of the puzzle.