Re:Overloaded: Is there simply too much culture?
by DeathArrow on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @02:05AM
(#29315314)
For me culture means Michelangelo, Umberto Eco and Shakespeare, not House of Cards, Girls, Squid Game.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Overloaded: Is there simply too much culture?
by YeBanKo on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @02:56AM
(#29315583)
How is Shakespeare different or better than let’s say Girls or Squid Game? I think it is exactly what it was, Girls and Squid Game of its time.
Michelangelo is definitely out of this world. My favorite of his works is Pietà. Every time I looked at it for half an hour and just could not believe the realism. However, while Renaissance was great foe find arts, there is a lot of mediocrity. We are looking at the best, the rest is forgotten or only enjoyed by narrow group of connoisseurs.
Re:Overloaded: Is there simply too much culture?
by true_religion on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @03:26AM
(#29315743)
Well on the one side there are artists (e.g. Shakespeare) and on the other side is art (e.g. Squid Game).
I understand their reasoning in that classical auteur style works can be more culturally powerful, especially if they are old enough to serve as an example for their time periods. However, it’d be better to compare Michelangelo to any of the millions of sculptors who lived in the 500 years after him. Shakespeare can be compared to Broadway playwrights or movie screenwriters.
Re:Overloaded: Is there simply too much culture?
by scyzoryk_xyz on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @02:27AM
(#29315423)
Pretty sure Umberto Eco would be amused by being placed in that company.
Re:Overloaded: Is there simply too much culture?
by TickCount on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @02:35AM
(#29315467)
I absolutely love the show Girls. I loved it so much, I was positively depressed when it ended and I emailed Lena Dunham multiple times to BEG her to revive it. I literally witnessed myself turning into a "fanboy" like I'm 16 again. Normally, if I love something I have reason to consider a "guilty pleasure", I will feel reluctant to publicly say I love it for fear of being judged. But in the case of Girls (and Titanic), I have so often been moved to tears watching them, I have so often experienced the feeling (for me, the mark of great art, because it's the exact same feeling I feel when falling in love) of "death is no longer something to be afraid of because I've just caught a glimpse of something eternal, something that is bound to go on exist forever" - I have so often experienced such feelings watching them, that it's immediately clear to me that it'd be a silly betrayal of my entire being to try and pretend I don't love them. It would be no different from publicly joking about my mom's appearance just to fit in with the cool kids. Have you watched Girls? Yes, it's comedy. Yes it's often silly. But there is so, so much more to it. I'd go so far as to say that anyone who's watched Girls without becoming mesmerised by Lena Dunham by the end, has not really watched the show.
Re:Overloaded: Is there simply too much culture?
by Kiro on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @02:55AM
(#29315575)
Wow, haven't watched Girls but I'm sure I will after this comment. That's one of the most convincing reviews I've read.
Re:Overloaded: Is there simply too much culture?
by tgv on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @03:29AM
(#29315757)
The problem with calling entertainment low culture is that it cheapens the original concept while still trying to get the same appreciation and respect for it. Perhaps we should forsake the word "culture" and call it "art" again. And no, "House of Cards" is not art.
Re:Overloaded: Is there simply too much culture?
by reginold on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @02:55AM
(#29315580)
This definition seems myopic - yes to old/dead white men but excludes women and asians.