Re:Ask HN: Why can’t big cities buy up small towns?
by b0ner_t0ner on Sunday November 21, 2021 @10:24AM
(#29296790)
> Why would people of NYC support spending their taxes on subsidies to some other town's people and explicitly giving housing priority to "others" over the current voters of NYC?
If you see people’s homes get destroyed year after year, wouldn’t it be of service to help these climate-crisis refugees move to safer cities rather than waste the tax money to help them rebuild their home only to get destroyed again next year?
Re:Ask HN: Why can’t big cities buy up small towns?
by PeterisP on Sunday November 21, 2021 @11:11AM
(#29297258)
I don't see how that's related - the tax coffers of NYC (which is not the same as e.g. federal budget) are currently not being used to help rebuild the flooded houses in smaller cities; and it would not make sense for NYC to start using the NYC's infrastructure money for fixing problems of other municipalities.
Also, there's no option for people to "get moved" - you can offer incentives for them to move, but they have the right to stay on their property and to vote for people who promise to maintain their local infrastructure instead of transferring them somewhere else.
Furthermore, in the specific example situation you describe, there's a significant expense to NYCity (essentially, buying up lots of valuable land and abandoning it) and no clear benefit for the citizens of NY City, which their government is supposed to represent. Why would people of NYC support spending their taxes on subsidies to some other town's people and explicitly giving housing priority to "others" over the current voters of NYC? The incentives don't seem to be aligned there.