News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:LLVM relicensing update and call for help by jcelerier on Sunday November 21, 2021 @07:11AM (#29295799)
I have yet to see BSD / MIT meaningfully improving my personal life, quite unlike the GPL which pretty much made my career possible thanks to the wealth of GPL software under Linux
Re:LLVM relicensing update and call for help by Xylakant on Sunday November 21, 2021 @07:36AM (#29295898)
Have you ever used software linked against OpenSSL? It’s licensed under APL, which is very similar to the BSD family of license - it allows use in closed source projects. Or OpenSSH - it’s developed by the OpenBSD folks and licensed under a BSD style license. Or Firefox - licensed under MPL, very similar to APL. The rust compiler is dual-licensed under MIT/APL. Both ruby and python are dual-licensed with at least one license from the BSD/MIT group, the python license itself is similar to BSD as well. The Linux kernel allows incorporating BSD/MIT licensed code in the kernel itself and though I didn’t check, I’m certain there are examples.
Re:LLVM relicensing update and call for help by jcelerier on Sunday November 21, 2021 @11:02AM (#29297164)
> Have you ever used software linked against OpenSSL? It’s licensed under APL, which is very similar to the BSD family of license - it allows use in closed source projects.

well, if I could I'd definitely choose gnutls over it even before getting to licensing issues tbh. Also how much better did it being useable in closed-source projects (those I don't use unless there's really no other viable choice and doing it myself is not an option) make it ?

> Or OpenSSH - it’s developed by the OpenBSD folks and licensed under a BSD style license.

yes, though I'm not sure if I'm using any openssh-specific interface, ssh -X maybe ?

> Or Firefox - licensed under MPL, very similar to APL.

MPL is closer to GPL in spirit than MIT/BSD, no ? AFAIK you can't make a closed-source derivative of Firefox (which is what matters).

> The rust compiler is dual-licensed under MIT/APL.

I don't use it. The only Rust software I'm using is ripgrep I believe ?

> Both ruby and python are dual-licensed with at least one license from the BSD/MIT group, the python license itself is similar to BSD as well

I don't use either neither as a developer or a user, the huge majority of my direct interaction with my computer is through C or C++ software; mainly KDE stuff.

But all of this is besides my point - if there wasn't a big ecosystem of (L)GPL software existing when I was a teen (Linux, KDE, core/binutils, GCC etc) I'm not sure I could have taught myself enough computing to achieve what I seek to. If everything was BSD I doubt these software would have evolved into something good enough to make for a correct desktop experience (last time I tried a BSD it was deeefinitely not useable enough for me unless replacing most of the BSD base with the GNU one like I do on my mac machines for instance). I've also used proprietary software for instance, but I would not say they made my life "meaningfully better".

Re:LLVM relicensing update and call for help by my123 on Sunday November 21, 2021 @09:09AM (#29296296)
> and though I didn’t check, I’m certain there are examples.

The whole GPU driver subsystem for example.

Re:LLVM relicensing update and call for help by fault1 on Sunday November 21, 2021 @04:19PM (#29299831)
It's debatable that most GNU stuff would be available if it were not for BSD.