News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Best cars without too much digitalization? by worldmerge on Friday November 19, 2021 @04:36PM (#29282859)
Saab 900 with a Mach E crate motor swap.
Re:Ask HN: Best cars without too much digitalization? by cmrdporcupine on Friday November 19, 2021 @04:41PM (#29282926)
Wouldn't work well, that crate motor is made for transverse mounting, the 900 is famous for its longitudinal & backwards motor (and perfectly balanced to avoid torque steer).

A good candidate for a Tesla drive unit transplant, probably. Too bad I don't have the mechanical skills to do it myself (I have a non-running 1984 900 SPG in my garage)

Re:Ask HN: Best cars without too much digitalization? by KennyBlanken on Saturday November 20, 2021 @01:03AM (#29285938)
It's an integrated drive unit, just like the Tesla drive unit (with the exception that the Tesla includes an inverter in the IDU; the Eluminator, sadly, does not.)

The only thing you'd need is a cradle and custom half-shafts.

Re:Ask HN: Best cars without too much digitalization? by jsight on Friday November 19, 2021 @04:48PM (#29283003)
Isn't the Tesla drive unit also mounted transverse? Or do you mean that there are more aftermarket solutions to resolve this for Tesla drive units?
Re:Ask HN: Best cars without too much digitalization? by cmrdporcupine on Friday November 19, 2021 @04:54PM (#29283076)
It is mounted transverse it's kind of set out in a way I can see it fitting in the 900 chassis ok. I haven't physically measured it, but I think it could drop in from eyeballing it.

But the big reason is that the Tesla units include the gear reduction to directly attach to the short axles. The 900 has a funny arrangement where the engine is part of a whole transaxle unit which sits on top of the transmission and oil pan, drives the transmission by a chain, and then the axles hang out the side of the unit. I think the Tesla units could drop right in there, just need new axles.

There's a couple Model S rear drive units hanging around in local classifieds. I've been tempted but I don't think I can justify spending $$ on yet another project I'd never finish.

Re:Ask HN: Best cars without too much digitalization? by KennyBlanken on Saturday November 20, 2021 @01:09AM (#29285961)
The Tesla unit is offset transverse whereas the Eluminator is coaxial. Both are integrated drive units - electric motor and gearbox.

Telsa includes the inverter in the drive module; the Eluminator requires an external inverter, unfortunately.

Quite the missed opportunity, because it would be nearly drop-in if it included an inverter. That's what is so great about the Tesla module. You feed it power and CAN bus commands and boom, you've got torque.

Re:Ask HN: Best cars without too much digitalization? by cmrdporcupine on Saturday November 20, 2021 @07:32AM (#29287522)
Yep, and the Tesla units are also more compact and from looking at the Eluminator it doesn't attach directly to the short axles, would require some other gearbox attached, no?

I suspect the inverter was not released with it because there is IP there that they cannot give away / sell. Tesla wouldn't either, you can only get that drive unit by salvage.