As far as deeds to important things; you can lose the title to your house in the current system too. It's why you pay for title insurance.
Would I like my home dependent on me never loosing a 128-bit key? Probably not. I'm fine with Ticketmaster and the paper title to my house. But my examples are at least a million times better than the hosted JPEG stuff, which I think was the only bar I had to cross. :D
With possibilities ranging from they didn’t actually own the house, to they were mentally competent to make the decision, to the house was incorrectly registered in the gov systems.
You would still need this in a title-in-NFT world, because an NFT is just supplanting the government title office, which is actually the final source of truth on ownership (not the literal paper title).
And like the government office, which is really acting as a convoluted database (which is all the NFT chain is doing as well), you still have all the problems of dealing with fallible humans.
It’s basically a case of the naive rewrite — the current solution is too complex, so we’ll scrap it and start over… without realizing some of the complexity was accidental, but it was largely essential from dealing with all the edge cases.
With NFTs you'd need title insurance in the exact opposite direction. You'd need to insure your title to make sure that a fraudulent and irreversible NFT transaction didn't irrevocably transfer ownership of your house and leave you boned.
And also, the bar I set was "better than a database" not "better than a poorly drawn JPEG".
I still genuinely think lower value things like concert tickets are better in a shared database rather than a private one, especially since I trust the owner of the private database (Ticketmaster) exactly as far as I can throw them.