News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Seattle residents launch Approval Voting initiative for r... by troydavis on Thursday November 18, 2021 @10:32AM (#29266537)
I'm co-leading this initiative. It's democracy, not politics: a simple, non-partisan, candidate-neutral change that leads to far more representative[1] winners.

If anyone would like to invest time or money to make this happen, please contact us or donate here: https://SeattleApproves.org/

[1]: https://electionscience.github.io/vse-sim/VSEbasic/ , https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7btAd1HYvjU&t=1329

Re:Seattle residents launch Approval Voting initiative for r... by wfhpw on Thursday November 18, 2021 @12:50PM (#29268294)
My prior intuition was that rank-choice voting would be preferable to approval voting, but this [1] was pretty helpful. Thanks!

[1] https://electionscience.org/library/approval-voting-versus-i...

Re:Seattle residents launch Approval Voting initiative for r... by troydavis on Friday November 19, 2021 @11:21AM (#29278821)
You’re welcome! You might also enjoy the concrete example (from a recent Seattle primary) here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29266519#29277580
Re:Seattle residents launch Approval Voting initiative for r... by ISL on Thursday November 18, 2021 @03:10PM (#29269832)
What blocks us from attempting a similar approach state-wide? Seattle's top-two approach has already made a big difference in making the general election relevant and competitive.

Where I see trouble these days is with Federal elections. Being able to vote for anyone but X or Z would be a wonderful way to send a signal as a voter. I suspect that both the east and west sides of the state would feel similarly (East: "Anyone but X!", West: "Anyone but Y!". Result: M gets elected, who is thankfully neither X nor Y.).

Re:Seattle residents launch Approval Voting initiative for r... by troydavis on Friday November 19, 2021 @08:57AM (#29277135)
Sorry for the late response. I wasn't on HN yesterday.

Someone else answered this well, but: money. A Seattle initiative is roughly 10%-20% as expensive as a statewide one, and it's still an incredible challenge to raise enough to do this. Ask me where I spend my time.

Qualifying for the ballot in Seattle requires about 26,200 valid signatures (10% of votes cast in the last Mayoral election). They must be collected during a 180-day period that, due to deadlines to make the November ballot, must is basically January-June. Since January-March is wet and cold, people aren't outside as much and many initiatives just do April-June.

Collecting 26,000 signatures in 90-180 days is all but impossible with volunteers, which means the core challenge for an initiative is fundraising to pay signature-gathering costs. You can divide 26,000 by any number of valid signatures collected per hour - 3, 6, 12, whatever - and it's still a lot of time and thus really expensive.

So, that's for the Seattle ballot. Getting on the WA state ballot requires 324,516 (!). Yes, 12x more. And that cost scales roughly linearly; the few efficiencies of scale are offset by new inefficiencies like travel. There's some efficiencies with overhead, but that's a small % of the cost.

So, that's why. It takes 5-10x more money.

Of course, voters would need to support it statewide too. In Seattle, this will pass; our job is to get it on the ballot. A statewide campaign may also need to do at least an education/awareness campaign (roughly the last paragraph of your comment) and potentially even try to change public opinion. These can cost even more than collecting signatures.

(If you're reading this and thinking "Wow, Troy knows this stuff - and it's interesting and there's a plan to do this!" - it is and there is! I'd love your help as a volunteer and/or your donations.)

Re:Seattle residents launch Approval Voting initiative for r... by godelski on Thursday November 18, 2021 @04:25PM (#29270785)
> What blocks us from attempting a similar approach state-wide?

Same thing that makes it difficult by attempting to do it country wide. That it is larger and more difficult. It would be nice if we could just wave a hand and change everything at once, but that also wouldn't be very democratic. What is also nice is that we can experiment, refine, and test at smaller levels before we advance to larger elections.

Re:Seattle residents launch Approval Voting initiative for r... by otterley on Thursday November 18, 2021 @12:46PM (#29268248)
Can you compare this against ranked-choice voting with instant run-offs?
Re:Seattle residents launch Approval Voting initiative for r... by godelski on Thursday November 18, 2021 @02:15PM (#29269246)
The first link there does actually compare against ranked choice. It is just called IRV. There's a larger comparison that includes more types of ranked choice (also called "ordinal") here[0]. Though I particularly like this animation[1]. I'll also add that there is a lot of nuance to voting and VSE isn't everything. There's a lot of factors to consider including: how do strategies work? Is it scalable? Can it easily be counted and/or verified statistically? How easy is it for voters? How effective are (strong and weak) spoiler candidates? And many more questions. For the most part cardinal methods (like Approval) fair better on all these accounts. There is a slight tradeoff to VSE. Note STAR in [0] has a slightly lower VSE than RP/Schulz (ranked), but a tighter grouping (better vs strategies). But also STAR is more complex for voters and counting than Approval is (I'd still argue STAR is easier for voters and counters than ordinal systems). So these are the types of tradeoffs you're making

[0] https://electionscience.github.io/vse-sim/VSE/

[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-4FXLQoLDBA

Re:Seattle residents launch Approval Voting initiative for r... by clairity on Thursday November 18, 2021 @03:19PM (#29269965)
i'd actually love to see a voting system developed that's closer to a conjoint, which is a statistical method designed to reveal preferences, rather than relying on stated preferences (which are notoriously unreliable). it's more complicated, but we have plenty of technology nowadays to make it practical.

one method of implementing this (from thinking about it for all of 2 minutes), is developing a list of the top 10-20 issues that voters care about in a given election and providing tradeoff choices for each, then matching them to the candidate closest to their revealed preference. of course, the biggest issue with method is that it moves the problem up one level, from voting to choice design.

[0]: https://wikipedia.org/wiki/Conjoint_analysis

Re:Seattle residents launch Approval Voting initiative for r... by godelski on Thursday November 18, 2021 @03:34PM (#29270156)
I honestly think it is very difficult to determine what voters' actual preferences are. I mean think of your standard political compass tests. Or even Meyer Briggs. They can change day to day or mood to mood and lots of questions tend to be leading. While I love the idea, I think logistically it would be a nightmare and greatly reduce transparency. It would also be far more vulnerable to so called experts manipulating the system if they aren't acting in good faith.
Re:Seattle residents launch Approval Voting initiative for r... by clairity on Thursday November 18, 2021 @04:05PM (#29270538)
it's exceedingly difficult to fairly aggregate voter preferences, but all current voting systems seem to reduce all that complexity down to a singular choice in the overwhelming majority of cases. that's a shitload of information discarded, to put it crassly.

the neat thing about conjoint is that it multiplexes the choice-making (when designed well), so that the choice burden scales reasonably while also better representing collective choice. nothing is going to be perfect, but conjoint could potentially be better than all current systems, probably by an order of magnitude or more.

it's relatively complicated, so yes, 'experts' (i disdain this term, frankly) could in theory manipulate the system, but transparency of voting data (just like now) and survey design (the more likely bias vector) would make that difficult. transparency would allow competing independent journalists, academics/researchers, political analysts, etc. to weigh in and balance out biases (not perfectly of course), as well as verify results.

Re:Seattle residents launch Approval Voting initiative for r... by emaginniss on Thursday November 18, 2021 @05:35PM (#29271495)
Sorry, but I think that's a terrible idea. Unless we're talking about ballot initiatives, I would hate for us to focus more on policy-based voting. What we should be doing as citizens is voting for someone based on our belief that they will represent our interests in the long-term. If you vote for someone solely because they agree with you on a couple of issues, you could be voting in someone truly reprehensible. I would prefer to vote in someone with integrity that I disagree with than someone untrustworthy that says the things I want to hear.

Additionally, all of this ignores the possibility that a representative could change their stance on an issue after receiving more information on an issue. Presidents and Supreme Court justices have changes their stances once their terms have begun or events have taken place during their time in office. I would hate a system that relies on tightly binding the representatives to narrow definitions of hot-button issue stances.

Re:Seattle residents launch Approval Voting initiative for r... by stocknoob on Thursday November 18, 2021 @04:15PM (#29270679)
Referendums exist to get a state-wide policy change. In the last election, historically conservative states voted for liberal policies like legalized marijuana, $15 min wage, etc.

For politicians, for me, it's more about (perceived) character vs. their stated policies.

Re:Seattle residents launch Approval Voting initiative for r... by clairity on Thursday November 18, 2021 @05:18PM (#29271358)
you could certainly include character traits among choice decisions, but that's more fraught by subjectivity. that said, that's the magic of conjoint done well: turning subjective hidden preferences into (more) objective choice revelation.

currently, there is no option to choose a candidate supporting marijuana legalization, $15 minimum wage, pro-life, and pro-gun policies (as an example), since we practically only have two relatively fixed packages of pre-ordained, all-or-nothing policy positions to choose from. revealed preferences would pressure parties into fielding candidates that better match the non-partisan preferences of constituents. or better yet, it would lead to the waning of the two-party system altogether, toward a more direct representative democracy.

Re:Seattle residents launch Approval Voting initiative for r... by hollasch on Thursday November 18, 2021 @05:33PM (#29271486)
That would work if all candidates are interchangeable if they assert the same plank. In practice, however, candidates X and Y may both have identical planks but wildly different levels of efficacy. People aren't machines.
Re:Seattle residents launch Approval Voting initiative for r... by troydavis on Friday November 19, 2021 @09:37AM (#29277580)
Other people gave good answers about how this compares to RCV/IRV (thread: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29266519#29269246), and both of the links in my first footnote above (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29266519#29266537) cover it.

That's all academic, though. A great real example is the 2021 Seattle City Attorney primary, which had only 3 candidates. The votes were split: 36%, 32%, 30%. These 2 candidates emerged from the primary: https://www.nytimes.com/2021/10/30/us/seattle-city-attorney-.... The candidate that most accurately represented the opinion of the electorate, Holmes, was eliminated. That would have still happened in a ranked ballot. The voters who voted for Thomas-Kennedy or Davison in our current system would have still put Thomas-Kennedy or Davison #1 in a ranked ballot.

I tried to distill this in https://twitter.com/troyd/status/1461389190206156802. And a 3-way race like that is actually the simplest possible case. Effects like that are much more likely with more candidates and they happen everywhere in the elimination cycle, they’re just less obvious to casual observers. That's what you see in https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7btAd1HYvjU&t=1329 (note that IRV == RCV in that video).

(Obligatory disclaimer: I don't care who wins. I do care how accurately the winners reflect the inputs, namely, voter opinion.)

Separately, Washington law requires cities hold a primary that produces 2 candidates for the general election, so cities can't legally eliminate primaries. That said, whether primaries are a net positive or negative is a really complicated discussion. Beyond election mechanics, the disadvantage of primaries is that only a subset of voters in the general will turn out in the primary. The advantage is that voters don't spend much time on ballots and it focuses that time. Seattle had 15 candidates for Mayor (many races are 10+). If someone spends 10 minutes on their ballot and the ballot has 10 races, that's 1 minute per race - 6 seconds per candidate. No easy answer here. However, for practical purposes we don't need to answer that hard question; this one change delivers an incredibly representative election.

Re:Seattle residents launch Approval Voting initiative for r... by slownews45 on Thursday November 18, 2021 @02:17PM (#29269257)
I've seen approval voting up close, approval and top 3 make it to council seats.

One issue seems to be domination by majority?

For example, let's say 55% of electorate is hard left, 45% moderate to conservative.

Under approval those 55% can vote for all 3 lets say hard left candidates, no moderate's make it in?

RCV, once someone has gotten their candidate in, their vote is exhausted. Seems to come out much better. Still might end up with 2 hard left, one moderate, but that seems fairer to me.

Re:Seattle residents launch Approval Voting initiative for r... by ClayShentrup on Thursday November 18, 2021 @02:58PM (#29269684)
This is actually completely backwards. IRV favors extremists whereas approval voting tends to find the most broadly appealing candidate.

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=-4FXLQoLDBA

Re:Seattle residents launch Approval Voting initiative for r... by slownews45 on Thursday November 18, 2021 @03:24PM (#29270031)
That's not how its working here. We are getting near 100% representation from about 56% of votes.

The ballot is approval style voting, you can vote for X of Y candidates.

Re:Seattle residents launch Approval Voting initiative for r... by jpfed on Thursday November 18, 2021 @04:42PM (#29270987)
As others have said, if they're limiting the number of approvals you can make on your ballot, then that's not how approval voting is supposed to be administered.

If they're just adding up each candidate's votes, that's not how approval is supposed to be tabulated in a multi-winner context (which is more complicated); see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Proportional_approval_voting

Re:Seattle residents launch Approval Voting initiative for r... by xvedejas on Thursday November 18, 2021 @04:19PM (#29270719)
if X is a fixed number, then it's not approval voting. In approval voting, there is no limit, either minimum or maximum, on the number of candidates you can vote for. If X is limited, then you get something a bit more like plurality voting, since the spoiler effect is in play.
Re:Seattle residents launch Approval Voting initiative for r... by pxx on Thursday November 18, 2021 @04:23PM (#29270768)
That's not approval voting. If X is equal to the number of open seats that's literally just the definition of multiple winner plurality voting.

Approval voting is a single winner system.

Re:Seattle residents launch Approval Voting initiative for r... by ClayShentrup on Sunday November 21, 2021 @03:08AM (#29294895)
Approval voting means you can vote for as many as you want. It sounds like you're talking about at large plurality voting.
Re:Seattle residents launch Approval Voting initiative for r... by gowld on Thursday November 18, 2021 @02:24PM (#29269306)
Multi-winner elections are different from single-winner elections. Approval voting doesn't work there, because as you note, people with fewer acceptable preferences get fewer votes.
Re:Seattle residents launch Approval Voting initiative for r... by xvedejas on Thursday November 18, 2021 @04:21PM (#29270737)
Voters voting strategically are known to adjust their thresholds in approval voting to have the largest effect they can on the output, assuming they have some idea of the support base of candidates. That said, Range Voting is sort of a solution to this, and it's expected there that candidates will scale their top and bottom choices to the top and bottom scores respectively.
Re:Seattle residents launch Approval Voting initiative for r... by slownews45 on Thursday November 18, 2021 @02:54PM (#29269638)
Interesting, that limitation should perhaps be highlighted.

I think the appeal of the simple ballot is what drove adoption (ie, vote for as many as you like, top X win).

In California the trick is they treat all open seats as one office.

Re:Seattle residents launch Approval Voting initiative for r... by aldonius on Thursday November 18, 2021 @05:42PM (#29271550)
Did you have three votes, or more than three? If you had the same number of votes as there were positions to be filled, that's a plurality block vote. Winning slate takes all.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Multiple_non-transferable_vote

> RCV, once someone has gotten their candidate in, their vote is exhausted.

Hi, Australian here. What happens with multi-winner single transferable vote is that there's a _quota_ and then ballots for candidates who have reached quota get _reweighted_ (not quite the same thing).

This quota-and-reweighting system can (and must!) be applied to multi-winner Approval too - jpfed linked the wiki article.

Re:Seattle residents launch Approval Voting initiative for r... by pagibson on Thursday November 18, 2021 @04:03PM (#29270502)
Despite the claim that this isn't political, it's very difficult not to see this in light of the fact that Seattle's city council has the only elected Marxist in the U.S.

Kshama Sawant fought for the $15 minimum wage, the Amazon tax, numerous renters' rights protections, a ban on police use of chemical weapons against protestors, and is now continuing the fight for rent control. She's currently facing a right-wing recall campaign because big business was unable to defeat her in the 2019 election, despite Amazon dumping $1.5 million into various races for citywide office.

A few here have remarked that approval voting tends to select more "moderate" candidates over "extremes." This isn't a neutral preference, it's obviously ideological, and targeted at one specific legislator in Seattle. Voters should reject this measure as a transparent attack on the most effective and sincere fighter for working people in the country.

Full disclosure, Kshama and I are both members of Socialist Alternative. I may be limited in my ability to respond today, as I'm rushing right after work to a volunteer shift to make sure she stays in office. I'll try my best to check in occasionally!

Re:Seattle residents launch Approval Voting initiative for r... by troydavis on Friday November 19, 2021 @09:15AM (#29277317)
Sorry for the late response. I wasn't on HN yesterday.

Regarding:

> This isn't a neutral preference, it's obviously ideological, and targeted at one specific legislator in Seattle. Voters should reject this measure as a transparent attack on the most effective and sincere fighter for working people in the country.

This isn't ideological in any way, and it's not targeted at anyone. When I said it was non-partisan and candidate-neutral, it's really that simple. It's non-partisan and candidate-neutral.

Consistent with HN guidelines, I'd ask first for an assumption of good faith. Beyond that, I can give some practical comments:

1. Our group of volunteers includes a huge range of political beliefs. There is no "one" opinion that the group could try to target even if we wanted to. The shared belief is that leaders reflect public opinion as accurately as possible.

2. This doesn't help or harm anyone. Rather, think of the current system like a grocery store where, each time you walk in, the prices on every item have doubled or halved. No one wins today: one entity (sellers/candidates) has no idea what their real support is and the other entity (buyers/voters) has to cobble together ingredients for dinner.

That wouldn't be good for the dairy people and bad for the fish people, it's bad for all sellers/candidates and all buyers/voters. Our flawed system doesn't help anyone.

Imagine a system where every voter could express their whole opinion, without feeling like they were throwing away their vote. Every election becomes a simple measure of how many voters approve of each candidate.

3. Just practically, no one's job - politician or otherwise - is worth a year or two of my life. It violates the "The sun doesn't revolve around any of us" theorem :-) Heck, even if I got to personally pick every Seattle legislator, I wouldn't put in this much effort. I don't care anywhere near enough. The thing I care about, and the only thing that's worth this much effort, is a system that delivers whatever voters want.

PS: I would welcome your help making this happen! That's how much I mean it when I say this is candidate-neutral and we welcome everyone. As volunteers, our political preferences vary widely. Our commitment is to elect winners which best reflect voters' opinions (democracy), whether or not they match any of ours.

Re:Seattle residents launch Approval Voting initiative for r... by pagibson on Friday November 19, 2021 @11:46AM (#29279179)
Hey Troy, I appreciate the response! I buy that you aren't motivated by this one city council position in particular. But we can't escape the fact that every policy decision exists in our particular reality and has material effects. There's no such thing as an ideologically-neutral electoral system, of all things, because a change in system will select different candidates from the actual pool of existing candidates or types of candidates.

Wealthy elites don't care what policy choices are optimal in terms of some abstract desiderata[1], they push for the policies that will be best for them materially. Working people need to understand that and behave the same way.

To take a different example: Republicans in the U.S. push for voter ID laws because they favor Republican election outcomes. This is pretty well understood. A voter ID law appears on its face ideologically neutral. It still is meant to bring about a certain outcome, and should be fought on the basis of that outcome. It doesn't even matter if somebody pushing the legislation has a different intention, even a noble one!

---

[1] Incidentally, I'm not really sure how well AV even meets those desiderata. For example, does a non-Condorcet system really reflect voters' preferences most accurately? Later-no-harm is another criteria that comes to mind. I'm skeptical of the claim that AV is really "more reflective" in some objective sense than FPTP.

Re:Seattle residents launch Approval Voting initiative for r... by plandis on Thursday November 18, 2021 @05:24PM (#29271405)
> most effective and sincere

Those are not adjectives that I think the majority of people would ascribe to Sawant.

Re:Seattle residents launch Approval Voting initiative for r... by TulliusCicero on Thursday November 18, 2021 @04:39PM (#29270955)
This seems like a bit of a hot take. Are the people behind this initiative connected to conservative or anti-Sawant organizations?
Re:Seattle residents launch Approval Voting initiative for r... by abeyer on Thursday November 18, 2021 @04:55PM (#29271141)
Sawant and her supporters have had a pretty loose relationship with the truth in general, so I wouldn't put too much stock in that. It seems far more likely that if it's specifically in response to recent events that it's actually the fact that "conservative" (by Seattle standards, where we just elected the first republican in 30 years to a city office) candidates did quite well in the Nov elections where they were running against far left candidates and had squeezed out any more moderate voices in the primaries.
Re:Seattle residents launch Approval Voting initiative for r... by troydavis on Friday November 19, 2021 @10:57AM (#29278474)
> It seems far more likely that if it's specifically in response to recent events

I can answer this conclusively: it's not a response to any single election or event. We've been working on this for almost 2 years. Here's a tweet from June 2020: https://twitter.com/SeattleApproves/status/12776993817564528...

As we all say, correlation is not causality, but more practically, it's impossible to announce an initiative that addresses a real problem without it seeming related to something recent :-) Until the prior election is done, no one cares, and yet signature-gathering deadlines basically require starting as soon as that election ends.

(AMA about running an initiative, particularly one that doesn't have an enemy - that is, we're not trying to "Move the goalposts" towards or against any viewpoint. That's incredibly valuable (IMO!) and quite rare, but also means the typical you're-with-us-or-against-us fundraising and voter pitches don't apply. "You're with us if you support representative democracy" requires a different campaign plan targeted at people and organizations who support systems and incentives, not only candidates and positions, and who put their own preferences second to the will of the voters.)

Re:Seattle residents launch Approval Voting initiative for r... by pagibson on Thursday November 18, 2021 @07:03PM (#29272229)
That's a reasonable point, Ann Davison's victory could definitely be a factor as well. And I don't know much about the background of the petitioners here; I think it's likely they're sincere in their belief in the same way that the original recall petitioner probably is.

That doesn't change the fact that big business in Seattle would love to see Kshama out of office, and if she survives her recall and this initiative gains traction, I'm confident they'd throw their resources behind it to get another bite at the apple. With the exception of Sawant, they have a city government that works for them, and I think they'd prefer the middle path to rocking the boat in either direction.

Re:Seattle residents launch Approval Voting initiative for r... by TulliusCicero on Thursday November 18, 2021 @10:30PM (#29273486)
We shouldn't reject an otherwise-good improvement to the voting system just because one current politician might be negatively impacted.
Re:Seattle residents launch Approval Voting initiative for r... by godelski on Friday November 19, 2021 @02:23AM (#29274676)
> $15 minimum wage, the Amazon tax, numerous renters' rights protections, a ban on police use of chemical weapons against protestors, and is now continuing the fight for rent control.

As a moderate, are these extremist ideals now?