What's your definition of success? Google and Facebook federating?
Re:IRCv3 Spec round-up
by scrollaway on Thursday November 18, 2021 @08:36AM
(#29265179)
Federating is one goal but is useless without mainstream adoption.
Success is adoption. Enough users to break the network effect.
Signal is currently a good example of roughly the amount of users you need to start breaking the effect. So that's what success looks like. A very low bar version of it.
The question isn’t “If this can work with Matrix why not XMPP?”, the question is “Will Matrix have the same issues as XMPP?”