News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Mysteries the Standard Model can’t explain by casparvitch on Thursday November 18, 2021 @07:11AM (#29264538)
No, physicists are pretty comfortable with that one. It isn't immediately intuitive, but the models we have are powerful and predictive. There is of course a somewhat open question as to the interpretation of quantum mechanics. That question is almost metaphysics, whereas the problems quoted in the article are more holes in our present theory.
Re:Mysteries the Standard Model can’t explain by DangitBobby on Thursday November 18, 2021 @10:20AM (#29266410)
I thought the most surprising thing about wave/particle duality is that the act of observation itself is what causes the waveform of particles to collapse. Do we know of a mechanism for that? Are we not still surprised that you change the outcome of events by changing where you look?
Re:Mysteries the Standard Model can’t explain by ajkjk on Thursday November 18, 2021 @12:53PM (#29268325)
No one (today) really believes that it is the observation that 'causes' a change in the experiment. What is happening is that the observer is becoming entangled with the experiment.
Re:Mysteries the Standard Model can’t explain by DangitBobby on Thursday November 18, 2021 @07:40PM (#29272460)
I don't really understand the difference. It sounds like you're saying the act of observation entangles you, and the entanglement is the cause of the collapse. It's just adding one more link in the causal chain.
Re:Mysteries the Standard Model can’t explain by ajkjk on Friday November 19, 2021 @11:05PM (#29285470)
The difference is that there is no special thing called 'collapse'; when you write down the laws of physics, it doesn't exist. It's an emergent phenomenon, and it's not surprising that it happens, although it's very counterintuitive _if_ you are starting in the naive model of treating quantum waves like classical ones.
Re:Mysteries the Standard Model can’t explain by FeepingCreature on Thursday November 18, 2021 @10:35AM (#29266581)
As I understand it, collapse is an artifact of the necessity to derive classical results from an experiment. You can think of it as "at a certain scale, calculating this as a quantum system as opposed to classical is no longer worth it." But it's of course still a quantum system, because everything is quantum all the time.
Re:Mysteries the Standard Model can’t explain by DangitBobby on Thursday November 18, 2021 @07:46PM (#29272498)
I don't think so. The double-slit experiment demonstrates light acting as a wave in some circumstances and as individual photons in others [1].

> the basic version of this experiment, a coherent light source, such as a laser beam, illuminates a plate pierced by two parallel slits, and the light passing through the slits is observed on a screen behind the plate.[5][6] The wave nature of light causes the light waves passing through the two slits to interfere, producing bright and dark bands on the screen – a result that would not be expected if light consisted of classical particles.[5][7] However, the light is always found to be absorbed at the screen at discrete points, as individual particles (not waves); the interference pattern appears via the varying density of these particle hits on the screen.[8] Furthermore, versions of the experiment that include detectors at the slits find that each detected photon passes through one slit (as would a classical particle), and not through both slits (as would a wave).[9][10][11][12][13] However, such experiments demonstrate that particles do not form the interference pattern if one detects which slit they pass through. These results demonstrate the principle of wave–particle duality.[14][15]

This is the part I'm talking about, mainly.

> However, such experiments demonstrate that particles do not form the interference pattern if one detects which slit they pass through.

Once they are measured, you know where they are and they stop acting like a wave.

1. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Double-slit_experiment

Re:Mysteries the Standard Model can’t explain by FeepingCreature on Thursday November 18, 2021 @10:00PM (#29273302)
Well, as I understand it the problem is if you measure the slit the photon passes through, then the superposition is no longer "left slit or right slit", it's "left slit and sensor or right slit and not sensor", and the slit/sensor paired configuration can't interfere with itself anymore because the sensor state is different. In other words, this is what you'd expect to see collapse or no collapse.

For instance, consider https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Delayed-choice_quantum_eraser which demonstrates that the sensor state has to be part of the superposition instead of causing an irreversible collapse: if you store the detected slit until the photon hits the back wall, then delete it, an interference pattern emerges once again.

Re:Mysteries the Standard Model can’t explain by hdjjhhvvhga on Thursday November 18, 2021 @07:21AM (#29264603)
Well, they're comfortable because the phenomenon is well-studied, we have very good models and can with good accuracy predict what will happen. What we don't know is why exactly it behaves in this way.
Re:Mysteries the Standard Model can’t explain by khafra on Thursday November 18, 2021 @08:10AM (#29264978)
The word "why" (and other references to causation) don't work in a normal way when you're talking about fundamental physics, because fundamental physics is the lowest-level model within which causation takes place.

To ask "why" some part of the standard model is the way it is, you either invoke some rubric for comparing models, like Occam's Razor; or you indulge in metaphysics and speculate on the nature of whomever is running the Simulation. Either of these is a different meaning than the "why" of "why do rockets work in space."

Re:Mysteries the Standard Model can’t explain by hdjjhhvvhga on Thursday November 18, 2021 @08:28AM (#29265118)
Well, you made quiet a few assumptions here. We don't yet know how much fundamental quarks are and what (if anything) hides in the subquark level.

Given the lack of adequate instruments, our minds and unconventional approaches are our most powerful tools at this point. For example, we generally consider the space between particles as void. We can't see anything, we can't detect anything, so we assume there's nothing there. But for what it's worth, there could be trillions of unknown particles that don't interact with matter. So why would it matter, you ask? Because it's not impossible that under certain conditions some of these might cluster into matter or interact with it in unobvious ways. The existence of dark matter and energy (or the related phenomena) indicates this is not impossible.

But yes, I see your point. However, I hope we get deeper into understanding this phenomenon before I die. Who knows, maybe it's because of some yet-undiscovered aspect of photons, and metaphysical speculation is not necessary?

Re:Mysteries the Standard Model can’t explain by andrewgleave on Thursday November 18, 2021 @07:26AM (#29264641)
One explanation is the "Many-Worlds" interpretation of quantum mechanics: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Many-worlds_interpretation