This is "getting kicked out of the tribe" 101 and people are normally very sensitive to this. But as a new leader it's hard to understand all your status relationships (and that the happiness of the people under you on the org chart affects the happiness of the people listed above you).
You can disagree with everyone else, you can be overridden (and quit, or disagree and commit or whatever you have to do) but not to see it coming is to live in a fundamentally different reality than your team.
One thing I notice is a lot of words devoted to senior leadership and the author's personal leadership experience but not much focus on the experience or input of the (100+) people doing the work. The reason you don't fire a really good leader is because they'll take the team with them! The blog post is a bit of a Rorschach test but for me that's how I parse the blind spot.
I actually think it's a great blog post due to the Rashomon effect it seems to provoke among people who read it.
https://hbr.org/1983/09/moral-mazes-bureaucracy-and-manageri... https://www.lesswrong.com/tag/moral-mazes
I don't know if the isolation happened suddenly or gradually. I realized it all at once, but by the time I did, it had been happening for so long I don't know how it started. Somehow people stopped telling me what was going on and stopped consulting me on new decisions. I am the last person to find out about anything. One part of their existing pathology is a background churn of unilateral, unannounced, shuffling-the-deck-chairs "improvements" that cause a lot of errors and interruptions without making a worthwhile difference, but this is different. Even the changes that are formally talked about are talked about without me.
I know that leadership has my back (they came into the picture more recently and can see that the team is underperforming) and they are planning changes that include me, but other than management, which is detached from day-to-day work, I'm on an island. Reading between the lines, I think I was brought in to try to fix the team, but without any management authority (and management not involved day-to-day) and with the team just ignoring my ideas and trying to assimilate me into their way of doing things, I have accomplished almost nothing on that score. Meanwhile, my social isolation is such that I can't stand to stick around much longer. I am going to go somewhere where I can be part of a team again.
EDIT: Reading the article through fully, I think I should learn from his characterization of "swagger" (though I don't think the word is quite right.) When I wasn't listened to after repeated attempts to make the same point with the people who needed to hear it, I shouldn't have stopped talking. I should have kept saying the same thing whenever it was warranted. I should have talked louder. I should have taken my points to venues that included a larger audience than just the people who needed to act on them. I should have pressured management to put their weight behind me. I didn't do these things because I didn't want to be an asshole, and I didn't want to alienate people, and maybe because I was afraid of inviting open aggression against myself, but I should have been prepared to stand up to that. Why was I avoiding confrontation instead of inviting it? Maybe because I wasn't confident in my ability to argue my points in the face of hostility, but if that's the case, I should be practicing it more, not avoiding it.
If you are making any decision, it is on you to seek out and include all relevant stakeholders and include them. People should not have to walk around sniffing for meetings that they weren't invited to and pushing their opinions in so that they feel heard.
I trust my coworkers to include me if they want my opinion, and I trust them to make a good decision on their own if they don't!
Did the COO want to get what was on his mind so the company would lose nothing by firing him? Or was he utterly disappointed about said mind?
I really don't understand what any of this has to do with swagger.
Yet it is true you have to find it, and it's not obvious. Many times, what you're good at is what you can do better than others with less effort. But we can't see it because we associate value with effort; if it's easy for me then surely it's worthless?
Well, no. If it's easy for you (and difficult for others) then that's your trade.
In abusive environments, there is no logic, both things can be "true" at the same time. The COO wants to hurt him by firing him, but on some level also realizes that his contribution is valuable. Just because they want to get rid of him, that is no reason not to use him for one last time.
(Usually this works the other way round: people are told that they are worthless, but also that it would be highly irresponsible and unethical of them to leave. Somehow, both things can be "true" at the same time.)
If he had the confidence to come back to who he was, even after being targeted by jealous executives and messing up with one decision (splitting the eng team), he would have done a better job.
That’s my take of it
Given the meetings where decisions were being made were happening behind closed doors, he very well may have complained about a direction the CEO had chosen.
Too many blind spots.
1) He did great (like, there's actual metrics mentioned)
2) Others wanted a different direction (even though he did great?) and didn't tell him
3) They excluded him from meetings
4) They fired him
5) He blamed not "re-centering" himself
In the notes, he mentions that one of his later decisions (splitting engineering) was a bad choice. So isn't that the core of it, then?
The way he describes it, it sounds like the problem was him not being himself but it sounds like it's a simple management error that the others were too socially awkward to point out to him, instead firing him outright.