If you wonder how to split equity, check out the co-founder calculator I wrote at http://foundrs.com/calculator/index.php - it's fun to play with :-)
If you're not granting options to employees or you're just 3-4 founders, you can get the same effect as vesting with buy-sell agreements.
You can do vesting in LLCs (at least in most places, right?). You need a lawyer in any case.
That is almost literally true, only it's Nolo instead of Amazon.
LLCs, however, are a frigging nightmare. They're the most difficult form of business entity to set up (except for non-profit 501(c)(3)'s). Accounting for LLCs will require an experienced (expensive) accountant. Plus, state laws on LLCs aren't uniform in the states that matter.
Here's where I get jumpy on this stuff:
S- and C- corporations are complex enough to put people off until they get a lawyer. Most startup founders probably don't have a lawyer when they start.
When you say "LLCs are a nightmare", besides the fact that they're aren't for most people (they aren't even notably complicated for most people; that's the point), and that it's not that hard to switch out of an LLC when things get complicated (by that point, you have a lawyer)...
... besides those things, you're also probably effectively talking people out of incorporating at all. That's more than suboptimal; it's dangerous. It creates situations where you can be personally liable for all sorts of company expenses. We've had HN posts from people who were told by cofounders and business partners that they were personally liable for huge expenses, and had those same people discovered they owed zero because they were incorporated.
Don't do business as a sole proprietor. Get a structure with limited liability as soon as you can. If it's between an LLC now and an S-Corp "maybe 6 months from now, maybe earlier if we can find a good lawyer and we're making money" --- do the LLC.
You're the expert here. Where am I wrong in this analysis?
Funny, setting up our LLC took about 20 minutes of filling out forms and mailing them in. I've heard it's different state-to-state, but in the state we set up in (Virginia) it was not terribly harder than buying a new cell phone...and less money.
The S-Corp in particular has some attractive features: it simplifies equity grants to employees compared to an LLC, and taxes are easier to deal with in a C-Corp (there's also a sort of notorious salary-vs.-distribution trick people place with S-Corps to reduce their taxable income).
The LLC is incredibly easy to set up; you can probably get one via 1-click on Amazon now.
In the only company I founded that took serious VC, I didn't handle any of the legal, but the sense I got was that legal for a real VC round is so innately expensive that the S-to-C conversion isn't a big deal by comparison. It's most convenient for everyone if you're not even incorporated, but that's their problem (it is dumb to do business without incorporating); if you're worth funding, nobody is not going to fund you because of the cost of converting to their preferred structure.