That said, when you start talking 0.01% edge cases plenty of options open up. Burning fossil fuels at that scale for example is nowhere near a significant CO2 source compared to current releases. I fully expect hospitals to have backup generators and that’s not a significant issue.
I have no issues using hydro, I just don't think it should be placed in the reliable category. I think coal, gas, nuclear, etc should be in that category.
Of course total capacity on an annual basis basis varies. But we care about the ability to reliably produce power when necessary far more than maximum capacity across months. Markets adjust to supply limits on an annual basis far more easily than a power outage.
Hydro has some serious downsides for the ecosystem of whatever watershed it bottles up. Maybe newer implementations solve that?
Dams net climate change impact is very close to zero.
Their net climate change impact can only be considered close to zero when considered as offset fossil-fuel based sources. If they're emitting large amounts of methane and CO2 (until we get net 0 concrete), it seems extremely unlikely that the impact is close to 0.
In terms of concrete, the percentage of concrete produced worldwide that ends up in dams is minuscule. Only 34 states even have any hydroelectric dams. The US alone is producing 90 million metric tons per year, look for the most recent large hydroelectric dam in the US it wasn’t produced in 2021, or 2020, or 2019, or …
Also, moving solar power from California to Washington state and hydro from Washington state to California is cheaper than building excess generating capacity in each state. It’s already part of the same transition grid, transmission capacity is simply insufficient right now. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/North_American_power_transmiss...
CA uses ~15GW of gas power when the sun turns off at 6pm. It still uses 8-10GW of gas during the day when the sun is shining. That gas is going to increase another 2GW when Diablo canyon is switched off. During the day while solar is running it additionally imports 4-6GW from the NW and SW interchanges. When the sun turns off at 6pm it jumps up to 8GW sometimes more of imported electricity.
Meanwhile during the afternoon and evening the NW region is generating 20GW with fossil gas and coal power. While only managing to generate 16GW at these same peaks with its hydro power.
There is not enough hydro to do this, and you can't build more. CA is a power hungry state that has outsourced much of its pollution to other states. This is a result of targeting renewables rather than targeting clean power. It needs to build firm clean power, whatever form that takes. Targets should be for CO2 emissions. Not for some favored technology.
Currently, 5% of all solar power generated in California is wasted and that number keeps increasing because people just keep adding more solar. Storage is currently cost effective, and it’s only getting cheaper. More storage means building even more solar is again cost effective until eventually the grid ends up looking very different.
So you'd need enough solar to on the cloudiest of days to both keep things running with daytime demand in NW and CAL while still providing enough excess to (picking some numbers) charge up ~30% of the batteries, while the hydro runs to supplement charging the other ~30% of charge, so that overnight the 60% of charge can be drained in conjunction with the 20GW of hydro continuing to run. Why even rely on hydro if solar can still do all this, just build even more solar.
Seems shaky and fragile. And this is before you even get to solving the rest of North America.
To greatly simplify if daytime demand is 200GW and nighttime demand is 100GW. You build enough solar to in theory provide 600GW in optimal conditions and 60GW in the worst case accepting most of that is wasted. Still 90% of the time they provide 300+GW in the day which can charge batteries to provide 100GW at night. Which means 90% of days hydro is producing ~0 electricity.
The other 10% of the time solar is producing between 300GW and 60GW in the day. If it’s 299GW then hydro needs to supplement 1GW at night. If it’s only 60GW then hydro needs to supplement 140GW in the day and 100GW that night.
Now in the real world things aren’t that simple. Hydro isn’t a light switch, and wind is part of the equation etc, but as a first order approximation it works especially as you can use hydro to charge the same batteries that solar or wind would.
Also, dams don’t operate anywhere close to 100% 24/7, what I am describing is generally closer to a 2x increase in maximum generating capacity than 10x which isn’t free but the value of electricity produced would be vastly high more than making up for these costs.
I don’t get objections like this: There isn't the space for all that. That’s not an inherent limitation, people built these dams in the first place, we can remove them and build a new structure if that’s what it takes. Don’t flood properties downstream is a perfectly reasonable limitation, don’t build any new infrastructure isn’t. 2019 we produced 100x as much solar power as in 2009, change happens.
2X = 4c/kWh solar + batteries + wind + hydro solves the grid just about everywhere. US might only get 6.6% of annual electricity from hydro, but it’s already a huge grid scale battery storing up extremely intermittent rain into dependable power. 6.6% 100% of the time is already an 80+% solution 5% of the time.