Re:Journey to the Edge of Reason: The life of Kurt Gödel
by d4rkp4ttern on Monday November 15, 2021 @07:58AM
(#29226786)
I just finished reading it last week. I feel he could have shortened the initial 30 pages of the Austrian geopolitical environment, but otherwise really enjoyed it. It was a smooth read.
Was not aware of the previous biographies, thanks for sharing those. It is interesting that you’re saying the mental health story is not universally accepted.
Re:Journey to the Edge of Reason: The life of Kurt Gödel
by throwaway81523 on Monday November 15, 2021 @05:56PM
(#29234047)
I think it is universally accepted that Gödel was a great mathematician who suffered from mental illness. Budiansky's book seems to espouse a romantic but bogus notion that Gödel was a great mathematician because he suffered from mental illness. It doesn't work that way.
Re:Journey to the Edge of Reason: The life of Kurt Gödel
by d4rkp4ttern on Tuesday November 16, 2021 @10:01PM
(#29248904)
Ah I see what you meant. Somehow I didn’t pick up that interpretation from my reading.
Re:Journey to the Edge of Reason: The life of Kurt Gödel
by efm on Monday November 15, 2021 @09:04AM
(#29227489)
Correction: "Logical Dilemmas" by John Dawson
Re:Journey to the Edge of Reason: The life of Kurt Gödel
by pge on Monday November 15, 2021 @06:35AM
(#29226241)
Incompleteness by Rebecca Goldstein is also a fantastic bio of Gödel that captures the historical context and significance of his work
Re:Journey to the Edge of Reason: The life of Kurt Gödel
by throwaway81523 on Monday November 15, 2021 @05:52PM
(#29234001)
I have not read Goldstein's book, but multiple reviews by mathematicians said that while she did a careful and sensitive job on the biographical parts of the book, she completely messed up the mathematical parts. It's not that a biography needs to focus on technical details (that's what textbooks are for), but the author should at least understand them before writing about their significance. See Torkel Franzén's book for more about that.
But it seems to me, we already have a perfectly good Gödel biography, "Logical Dreams" by John Dawson, who is himself a logician, catalogued Gödel's Nachlass which probably made him the world's foremost Gödel archivist, and was also one of the editors of Gödel's Collected Works (5 vols).
Obviously I haven't read the new book so I can't compare directly, but my Bayesian prior is that if you're going to read just one, go with Dawson's.
If you're more interested in understanding the incompleteness theorem and the great amount of nonsense and confusion surrounding it, try "Gödel's Theorem: An Incomplete Guide to Its Use and Abuse", by Torkel Franzén, reviewed here:
http://www.ams.org/notices/200703/rev-raatikainen.pdf
Dawson's biography of Gödel is reviewed here:
https://www.ams.org/notices/200108/rev-davis.pdf