Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities
by seanmcdirmid on Sunday November 14, 2021 @10:42PM
(#29223421)
Property taxes are a useful tool against property speculation (which is why China is desperately considering one). Likewise, the fact that property tax is "stepped up" on sale also makes people less willing to sell (because they lose their sweet property tax valuation if they buy something else) and so pushes up the prices on the remaining second houses on the market. Grandma isn't going to move out of her 4 bedroom house because she is paying much less on property taxes than if she downsized to a two bedroom condo in the same area.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities
by 88840-8855 on Monday November 15, 2021 @01:17AM
(#29224345)
as you mention China - the property prices are declining there 3rd year in a row. in lower tier cities more than in Tier A, but also there they decline or stopped climbing.
we will have to wait and see how the common prosperity laws that Xi proposed will further change the life of people - and if they actually work, we must start thinking why WE were not able to do that in the first place with our democratic system that is supposed to represent the people.
Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities
by rcpt on Monday November 15, 2021 @01:34AM
(#29224438)
Tier A cities have been getting cheaper for 3 years?
Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities
by seanmcdirmid on Monday November 15, 2021 @12:23PM
(#29229848)
Tier 1 cities haven't, but Tier 88 cities have been. Actually, since the red families control most of the real estate companies, they often just prevent you from selling (real estate agents won't show your house) rather than risk scoring a "loss in real estate value." So in China it is better to look at sales volume rather than sale prices.
Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities
by rcpt on Monday November 15, 2021 @01:31PM
(#29230747)
I think that's intentional. I understand that to combat demographic disaster China has been depopulating the villages in favor of megacities. So tier 88 should get cheaper while tier 1 gets crazy.
Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities
by seanmcdirmid on Monday November 15, 2021 @02:47PM
(#29231774)
Tier 88 cities are hardly villages, they are cities with 1 million or more people. And they aren't shrinking, they are growing as well, most of China's growth will happen in these cities, especially since they are much easier to get hukou in than tier one cities. What good is living in Beijing if you can't send your kids to Beijing schools?
Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities
by seanmcdirmid on Monday November 15, 2021 @12:15PM
(#29229734)
China is looking for a long term solution, not quick fiat fixes from above. Despite all the mistakes they make, the Chinese government isn't dumb, they realize some continuous pressure against speculation in the property market will work better in the long term.
Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities
by reducesuffering on Monday November 15, 2021 @01:15AM
(#29224326)
Your second point is moot with the passage of Prop 19 transferring property taxes.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2020_California_Proposition_19
Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities
by rcpt on Monday November 15, 2021 @01:33AM
(#29224434)
Why would she move into a cheaper place and thus get a higher effective tax rate and pass less advantage on to her heirs?
But the whole conversation about Grandma is stupid anyway. The California Tax Postponment Program allows her to stay in her house, with zero tax pressure, forever. Plenty of states, even high property tax NJ, have something like that and it's just fine.