News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by Kalium on Sunday November 14, 2021 @08:34PM (#29222606)
Good news! California has a system in place in place that addresses exactly this problem: https://www.sco.ca.gov/ardtax_prop_tax_postponement.html It allows taxes to be deferred and taken out of the estate. Removing Prop 13 would leave this system entirely unaffected.

Your parents, assuming they are old enough to be seniors, will be fine. Your well-founded concern has been heard and handled. You can rest easy, knowing that your parents and other homeowning elders in California will not be forced out of their homes by property taxes they cannot afford.

Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by rcpt on Monday November 15, 2021 @01:36AM (#29224451)
Wow. Thank you for addressing this in such a friendly way. Every time I point it out I can't help but mock the successful owners but really your way of saying it is more effective
[dead]
Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by Kalium on Sunday November 14, 2021 @10:16PM (#29223255)
I don't understand. The thing the user was concerned about - their parents being forced out by taxes - is neatly prevented. What have I missed?

Or should I suppose that the goal is not keeping their parents where they are, but instead to inherit a valuable asset at exceptionally favorable taxation?

Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by throwawayboise on Sunday November 14, 2021 @10:12PM (#29223232)
Then the heirs lose out, they probably won't like that too much, nor will the pending decedents be happy knowing that a big chunk of their estate is going to be seized. I don't see how this is going to really make higher taxes more palatable.
Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by Kalium on Sunday November 14, 2021 @10:14PM (#29223242)
You'll have to pardon me if I have limited sympathy for the ability of the heirs to rich (defined here as multiple millions of USD in value) estates as they clamor to inherit tax rates from before their births. I understand the emotional pain of losing the all-important family home, but I am unwilling to structure public policy around vast tax breaks so that families flush with unearned wealth keep it.

Nobody likes paying taxes. It's literally never a pleasurable or enjoyable experience. Yet it's one that furthers society and allows it to do things like fund schools - a chronic problem in California.

Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by yongjik on Sunday November 14, 2021 @10:50PM (#29223471)
> Nobody likes paying taxes. It's literally never a pleasurable or enjoyable experience.

Not disagreeing with your points, but one major reason that it's "never a pleasurable experience" to pay tax in America is that ideologues deliberately designed the process to be as painful as possible, to give taxation a bad name. Sadly, it's working.

Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by kelnos on Monday November 15, 2021 @04:13AM (#29225355)
Too bad? Generational wealth transfer is the root of many of society's ills.

If parents bought a home in CA in 1980 for $300k, and then did little more than regular upkeep and minor improvements, and then die in 2021, why should their offspring be entitled to a $10M windfall? They've done nothing to earn it, besides being lucky to be born to parents who were lucky enough to be able to buy housing in an area that they were lucky enough to keep living in when that area became popular.

[dead]
Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by kelnos on Monday November 15, 2021 @08:15PM (#29235374)
Ah yes, "derangement". What a way to argue your case. You don't agree with me, so I must be deranged!

No one is an island. They did not achieve their wealth on their own, without benefiting from the commons. Accruing all those benefits to a single family's estate is not in society's best interests.

We already have estate taxes, income taxes, sales taxes, property taxes. We already have collectively agreed as a society that everyone needs to share in the cost of common services and infrastructure. From there it's just a negotiation as to how much. You seem to think people (especially rich people?) should get to pay less. I think they are not paying nearly enough, and have been fleecing the commons for centuries.

The idea that you think anyone who disagrees with your taxation policy is "deranged" speaks volumes.

Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by paisawalla on Tuesday November 16, 2021 @12:42AM (#29237292)
No, I just think it's a natural for society to encourage its members to invest in the long-term future of that society by way of endowing their children with the rewards of their investment and good fortune. That's a natural and universally understood principle, and it is indeed deranged -- i.e. a deviation for ordinary and healthy function -- to govern as though this is bad for society.

It's quite the uphill battle you've chosen, I hope you keep talking like "parents shouldn't be allowed to privilege their children" is a weird idea.

Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by Kalium on Monday November 15, 2021 @08:19AM (#29226985)
Anyone who has received the economic and educational benefits of a wealthy family has gained immensely by being heir. Plus the estate itself!

What's being proposed here doesn't stop generational wealth transfers. The suggestion at hand means that the owners of real property in California would have to pay (or defer) an amount of tax that's related to its current value. Inheritors would have to continue this, instead of inheriting a tax assessment from their parents or grandparents along with the ancestral pile.

A family is absolutely allowed to prioritize a child as the target of its earned resources and good fortune and exploitative practice or whatever. Potentially less a cut, because society has agreed to tax large inheritances. The family just shouldn't get to pass down an inherited tax break too. That's aristocratic, which is unacceptable in a free democracy.

Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by snidane on Monday November 15, 2021 @07:42AM (#29226652)
I think his point is, you don't get to pass wealth not earned by you to your heirs. You had nothing to do with 300k to 10m appreciation, so you nor your heirs are entitled to it. The appreciation is in land, not in the small improvements to the house. Owners never have influence on the price of land. That is strictly determined by the surrounding dwellings.
Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by rcpt on Monday November 15, 2021 @02:23PM (#29231468)
> Owners never have influence on the price of land.

One of the most frustrating thing about property tax discourse is that people feel like the fact that they hit the jackpot by accident is grounds for a tax cut. As if getting rich by the work of other is more deserving of a break vs. earning your own wealth.

Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by paisawalla on Monday November 15, 2021 @03:28PM (#29232264)
> Owners never have influence on the price of land. That is strictly determined by the surrounding dwellings.

But then the owners of those surrounding dwellings also had nothing to do with the appreciation of their houses, right? Only the owners of their surroundings added value, and so on. What a contorted argument you'd have to make, to claim that land somehow accrues value due to zero action of the people who happen to occupy it. Land appreciates because of the choices made by the community who lives there, e.g. to attract industry, prioritize certain uses, create or draw desirable businesses, etc.

The choices made by your parents, and the other parents from your previous generation, are almost entirely the reason why a the neighborhood you grew up in appreciates. And they make those decisions for your benefit, because they want to create wealth and community for you.

The responses to my comment confirm that yes, liberals absolutely believe nobody has a right to investment of their parents. What an alienating perspective, I hope you guys run with it and shout it from the roofs.

Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by snidane on Monday November 15, 2021 @04:01PM (#29232683)
You're right, it's the community and its actions that made the land appreciate. Surrounding dwellings and their occupants are just a part of that.

You can be entitled to inheriting the value that you and your parents created, wchi you'd somehow have to extract from the surrounding dwellings, the land of which appreciated due to your parents' good actions.

You are not entitled to appreciation of your land, because others in the community are responsible for it.

You essentially have these solutions:

  1. let land owners keep the value created by others in the community, which works only if 100% of members of the community have a piece land, and it has to be of equal value. This inevitably eventually results in a feudal system of landowners and serfs.
  2. Take the value of land appreciation from your neighbors properties and they take back value they added to yours. In theory this is is the ideal solution, but omits non-land owners who also contributed
  3. distribute the value back to the community responsible for creating the value in the first place by equal share using a citizens' dividend collected by land value tax which captures all the misallocated value appreciation
Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by Frondo on Sunday November 14, 2021 @10:35PM (#29223377)
I would defer to no less than a luminary like Thomas Jefferson in my attitudes toward the would-be inheritors of all those million-dollar ranch-style SDUs, who said something along the lines of..

> I set out on this ground, which I suppose to be self evident, "that the earth belongs in usufruct to the living": that the dead have neither powers nor rights over it.

(Though really, even before I knew of Jefferson's attitudes about inherited wealth, I'd read enough to know that divesting children of unearned windfalls isn't necessarily a bad thing. Can't take it with you, ya know.)