Most people on earth still live in conditions that are nowhere near the kind of development you are likely enjoying. They are also those who will feel the effects of man-made climate change most.
That is why this argument falls flat. We didn't buy this kind of living standard with some future self-inflicted suffering: your amenities of modern life are bought with the suffering of others.
But the deal is done and over. Now a debt is owed.
They still benefit from industrial development, even though with a certain time lag compared to us (because that is it: time lag. Living standards in poorer countries lag behind those of Europe or Japan, but they rise nonetheless.)
For example, about 90 per cent of humanity has electricity and uses some electrical appliances. Few people live in truly pre-industrial conditions.
You're right that it's not right to force still developing countries to halt their progress. I just wonder if there's a way to help them develop in a way that is better long-term.
Unfortunately, most of the activism seems to revolve around "us sinners" needing to abstain from our indulgences.
This is the "get rich by saving money" fallacy. Imagine all the CO2 of a century of industrial development had not been emitted. We'd be enjoying a life without man-made climate change, but also without any of the amenities of modern life.
Consider that air-to-fuel companies are pretty close to profitability with just a modest increase in carbon taxes. Consider also that countries like Germany spent a lot of money on transitioning to renewables, with very little to show for it. Once you picked the low-hanging fruit, there are no more "savings" to be had without drastically cutting down on production. At that point, you might as well turn some of that production into sequestration.
> So the whole thing seems like a fraud.
I get the same feeling with electric cars, solar panels and wind turbines. Why? Because these have all rolled out on account of lavish subsidies, not because the market decided they are the most efficient solution. Just put a price on CO2 and watch the market figure that one out. Results may be not what you expect.