News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:DoubleRecall (YC S11) Turns Paywalls Into Advertising Dol... by eli on Wednesday August 24, 2011 @01:50PM (#2921756)
Cute. I can see how it makes sense from a publisher perspective.

But it seems like an audience of the sort of people who would rather jump through hoops than pay a few bucks would not be very desirable to advertisers.

Re:DoubleRecall (YC S11) Turns Paywalls Into Advertising Dol... by webwright on Wednesday August 24, 2011 @02:21PM (#2921903)
In terms of audience... At $120 CPMs, I think this might be NICE for consumers-- ad-driven sites/apps need fewer ads to make a profit, can afford higher quality content with higher revenues, etc.

Read about priming studies and call it "cute" again... I dare ya! :-)

Here's a summary of some of Bargh's priming experiments I grabbed from http://jurylaw.typepad.com/deliberations/2007/05/two_interes...:

In one experiment, Yale's John Bargh gave subjects seemingly random word puzzles, with no apparent point or thread. Some of the puzzles containing a subtle preponderence of "old" words: Florida, gray, wrinkle, lonely, bingo. Walking down the hallway to leave after the exercise, the subjects who had the "old" words walked more slowly.

The same paper describes an experiment in which, when they finished the word puzzles, subjects were asked to find "the experimenter" to get their next task. The experimenter was always involved in an interminable conversation with someone else. Subjects whose word puzzles had scattered words invoking rudeness -- bold, rude, bother, disturb, intrude -- had no trouble interrupting. But a huge majority of subjects whose puzzles were full of "polite" words -- respect, considerate, appreciate, patiently, courteous -- never interrupted the experimenter's conversation at all.

---

With these studies in mind, I wonder about the impact of typing "diet coke skinny" in terms of brand recall AND in terms of behavior after the fact.

Re:DoubleRecall (YC S11) Turns Paywalls Into Advertising Dol... by eli on Wednesday August 24, 2011 @03:20PM (#2922147)
I'm not doubting the effectiveness of the ads, I'm doubting the quality of the people being exposed to them.
Re:DoubleRecall (YC S11) Turns Paywalls Into Advertising Dol... by troyp on Wednesday August 24, 2011 @03:49PM (#2922241)
Do you know whether the effectiveness is reduced if people know they're being primed?
Re:DoubleRecall (YC S11) Turns Paywalls Into Advertising Dol... by wmeredith on Wednesday August 24, 2011 @06:16PM (#2922696)
I have no citation, but I recall marketing studies that show that knowledge of priming has little to no effect on the subject. Which blew me away.
Re:DoubleRecall (YC S11) Turns Paywalls Into Advertising Dol... by tesseract on Wednesday August 24, 2011 @02:27PM (#2921930)
Often, the act of paying a few bucks online is sufficiently annoying (fill in billing address, think of a username and generate a password, fish out my credit card because I forgot the CVV2 code, wait for several page loads, etc.) that I would rather avoid it even if I don't mind parting with the money. On the other hand reading an ad and typing a few words sounds comparatively non-stressful, unless it is an overly long video ad.
Re:DoubleRecall (YC S11) Turns Paywalls Into Advertising Dol... by troyp on Wednesday August 24, 2011 @03:46PM (#2922234)
There are plenty of advertisers who would _target_ people who are worried about a few bucks, namely those advertising bargain products. Also, as mentioned previously, you have to "jump through hoops" to pay for an article anyway. Based on the example site, this method is much faster for the reader than a paywall anyway.
Re:DoubleRecall (YC S11) Turns Paywalls Into Advertising Dol... by tadruj on Wednesday August 24, 2011 @02:10PM (#2921849)
In brand advertising, it's all about exposure. Even one with no money to buy the article (or maybe not enough interest/motivation) can spread the word or endorse the brand to the ones who have money.

According to BJ Fogg of Stanford on Simplicity, one person is always floating in cartesian plane with time/money changing all the time and being a function of age, location, time of day.

One might have time and is not prepared to spend money and vice versa. And this can change during the day. So, if one gets a brand exposure in the morning when they have spare time to re-type two brand words, they might not have time in the afternoon when they're located at brand outlet, so they'll spend money.