News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:$25 PC alpha board successfully runs Linux by joezydeco on Wednesday August 24, 2011 @09:52AM (#2920658)
I wish people posting pictures would actually look at what they're posting.

The picture in this article looks to be a Broadcom evaulation board for the processor they're using (look at the silkscreen). That ethernet jack with integrated magnetics is $4 alone. There's no way this board is $25.

The actual board looks like this: http://www.geek.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/07/raspberry2.jp...

Re:$25 PC alpha board successfully runs Linux by poslathian on Wednesday August 24, 2011 @12:26PM (#2921314)
Agreed. That could be a dev board (seems pretty dishonest though). I was thinking it might be advertising. Lots of devboard companies do this - sell advertising space on the silkscreen to supplement their income on each unit (see digilentinc.com who does this a TON).

the $25 price point is out of the question unless: A) They sell at or VERY near cost B) They sell advertising on the PCB C) They are subsidized by a tech vendor selling them parts at a discount D) They are subsidized by a charity or an angel E) They are planning on making 100,000 units in one shot.

At least SEVERAL of the above have to be true, or the $25 is just made-up nonsense.

Re:$25 PC alpha board successfully runs Linux by icebraining on Wednesday August 24, 2011 @02:08PM (#2921841)
They say in the blog of the project that the model with Ethernet and 2 USB ports is $35. The pictures are probably from that model, not from the $25 one.
Re:$25 PC alpha board successfully runs Linux by poslathian on Wednesday August 24, 2011 @02:32PM (#2921956)
Even so, I cant find an ARM11 chip for less than 10$ on octopart, and in the 700MHz range its more like 20-30$ just for 1 chip. For qty purchases that can come down to 7.50, but thats being REALLY generous. I have trouble believing they can buy a 700MHz (unspecified on their materials and I couldnt get it off their snapshot either) for less than 15$. The headers and other plastic is at LEAST 4$, USB connectors alone are almost 1$ in qty 5000.

Add in the passives and other junk, and leave out the ethernet module and we are talking about a bill of materials of close to $20.

Now add 1.75 for the PCB (qty 5000), 2.50$ for assembly, another $2.00 for testing, packaging and assorted costs (like shipping raw materials and finished goods to and from china, since US assembly and PCB costs are at least 3 times what I noted) and the bare per-unit cost is $25.

Dont forget to factor in costs like - uhh - keeping the lights on in their officepartment - and even if their dev time is free they just cant sell that product for $25 without outside cash subsidizing the whole thing.

In this business, distributors pretty much demand the product at 25-40% discount, so if they want to be in shops and catalogs, you have to factor that in as well.

Consider the raw cost per arduino is probably around 10.50$, they sell 100,000 units a year, and their onboard processor is about 1$ and they have less overall plastic, passives, and other overhead parts than this thing.

Re:$25 PC alpha board successfully runs Linux by joezydeco on Wednesday August 24, 2011 @03:52PM (#2922252)
From reading more into the project, it sure looks like Broadcom is giving this group a significant helping hand.

Given that Eben Upton is currently a technical director at Broadcom while simultaneously working on this Raspberry Pi project...maybe I'm not so shocked anymore. It's actually refreshing to see chipmakers put out cheaper EVKs to play with instead of $4000 development systems. It's good marketing.

I'd single out TI as the largest culprit of making EVKs hard to get, but I'm also inclined to believe they've been giving Beagleboard/Pandaboard a helping hand (like where can you find loose OMAP4s on the market? I sure can't.)

Re:$25 PC alpha board successfully runs Linux by theatrus2 on Thursday August 25, 2011 @01:33AM (#2923868)
Broadcom would generally win on making hard to get EVKs. You can't even get data sheets unless you're a direct 100k unit type of customer. TI will sample to just about anyone.

Note that the OMAPs are trickier as they expose their memory bus above the chip - the SDRAM and NAND are mounted on top of the main die as a stacked BGA. This isn't easy to work with.

Re:$25 PC alpha board successfully runs Linux by joezydeco on Thursday August 25, 2011 @08:40AM (#2924674)
OMAPs are a godsend compared to Freescale i.MX. They still have pages and pages of design rules in their TRM about how to lay out the RAM busses. In fact I had Freescale recommend that I just cut-and-paste their reference design because they couldn't guarantee anyone else's design would ever work.
Re:$25 PC alpha board successfully runs Linux by ReadEvalPost on Wednesday August 24, 2011 @04:11PM (#2922320)
Maybe so for their higher end boards, but TI supplies the cheapest eval kit I know of at $4.30[1] for the MSP430 Launchpad.

[1] https://estore.ti.com/MSP-EXP430G2-MSP430-LaunchPad-Value-Li...

Re:$25 PC alpha board successfully runs Linux by keenerd on Thursday August 25, 2011 @02:32AM (#2923981)
Those don't count. TI is giving away those boards at a loss. TI likes to give away parts. The $4.30 is entirely (overnight!) shipping.
Re:$25 PC alpha board successfully runs Linux by anc2020 on Wednesday August 24, 2011 @10:00PM (#2923456)
Last login: Fri Aug 5 18:11:19 UTC 2011 from dc4-arm-01.cam.broadcom.com on pts/0

http://www.raspberrypi.org/?p=78#more-78

Re:$25 PC alpha board successfully runs Linux by keenerd on Thursday August 25, 2011 @02:28AM (#2923971)
> USB connectors alone are almost 1$ in qty 5000

Really? They are 40 cents, in quantities of 1. From Jameco, who are not known for their low prices. [1]

Your $4 for headers is bunk of a similar magnitude.

> I cant find an ARM11 chip for less than 10$ on octopart

This is true, but 500MHz Arm11 chips are only $11 in reasonably small numbers. [2]

I wish I was your supplier - you are putting their kids through college.

[1] http://www.jameco.com/webapp/wcs/stores/servlet/Product_1000...

[2] http://search.digikey.com/scripts/dksearch/dksus.dll?Detail&...

Re:$25 PC alpha board successfully runs Linux by poslathian on Thursday August 25, 2011 @09:41AM (#2924847)
hah. Yea I think perhaps I was a bit hot on those estimates. Its neat vendors practically give away some of these eval kits for marketing (which is almost certainly what this is, guised under a charity...), but it makes life awfully hard for me when clients now expect their 5000 unit run ARMx single board computer should cost about 15$ a pop (totally unachievable) plus engineering. I still hold on to my conclusions.

Without breaking down everything piece by piece, we spend about 3.00$ in plastic and other headers on a medium qty design that looks about comparable to what theyre doing (i/o wise). Also, female 1/10" headers are quite a bit more expensive than male, which I think skewed my intuition a bit.

Re:$25 PC alpha board successfully runs Linux by mjschultz on Wednesday August 24, 2011 @09:58AM (#2920678)
Their own site has the same pictures that are on the original post: http://www.raspberrypi.org/?p=78

Looking through the media section says that the picture you have is a prototype board, not the manufactured alpha board they're talking about here.

Re:$25 PC alpha board successfully runs Linux by icebraining on Wednesday August 24, 2011 @10:10AM (#2920713)
The Model B ($35), which they refer to in the post, does have an ethernet jack with magnetics.