Re:Why Zulip will not get on the blockchain bandwagon
by rp1 on Friday November 12, 2021 @07:05PM
(#29206015)
You should try writing a smart contract. I didn’t believe in the utility until I did that. You can think of a blockchain like Ethereum as a really shitty global computer. It’s so weak that all it can do is transactionally change a few bytes of data associated with a key. Using this shitty computer, you can implement a currency or some type of token system. The important bit is that it’s a shitty computer _now_, but maybe it won’t be so bad in the future. When you implement a smart contract, you realize it’d be pretty nice if you could run complicated programs on a global computer and not need to worry about running your own infra like a DB or hosting.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Why Zulip will not get on the blockchain bandwagon
by Ekaros on Friday November 12, 2021 @07:13PM
(#29206069)
Single or even handful of global computers running everything sounds extremely scary... Something goes wrong or there is some issue and whole thing comes to halt with decent chunk of economy... Then fights start how to fix it. How to roll things back. What to reinstate. How that effects further things. What if at this point some physical transactions have happened?
Are we going back to 40s and world needing 4 computers?
Re:Why Zulip will not get on the blockchain bandwagon
by threeseed on Friday November 12, 2021 @07:12PM
(#29206067)
> could run complicated programs on a global computer and not need to worry about running your own infra like a DB or hosting
You mean like serverless ?
Re:Why Zulip will not get on the blockchain bandwagon
by rp1 on Friday November 12, 2021 @07:17PM
(#29206104)
Serverless is just the execution context. You still need to worry about data storage. As I said, I didnt understand the difference until I tried to build something. It just feels different than serverless. One thing is that you still need maintain your serverless setup. If you stop paying the bills, your app dies. That doesn’t happen on the blockchain.
Re:Why Zulip will not get on the blockchain bandwagon
by evergrande on Friday November 12, 2021 @07:18PM
(#29206110)
Except those companies can decide to change the rules at any time and can kick you off. And that's increasingly on the basis of mob rule and authoritarian governments.
Re:Why Zulip will not get on the blockchain bandwagon
by kmarc on Friday November 12, 2021 @07:15PM
(#29206089)
This is what a couple of my former colleagues worked on under the name of "internet computer". No affiliation, but I find it interesting.
Re:Why Zulip will not get on the blockchain bandwagon
by evergrande on Friday November 12, 2021 @07:12PM
(#29206064)
Try deploying the same contract on a different chain, like Polygon. It's a lot more fun. Super cheap, almost instant and is a preview of the future. If ETH 2.0 is like that it'll be a game changer.