News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:Liberal Hypocrisy Is Fueling American Inequality. Here’s ... by dang on Saturday November 13, 2021 @02:51PM (#29212633)
Please do not take HN threads into political flamewar hell. We're trying for something different on this site.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Liberal Hypocrisy Is Fueling American Inequality. Here’s ... by mionhe on Friday November 12, 2021 @01:20AM (#29196774)
Erm, these areas have internet and go to school like anyone else. They're plenty exposed.

What does "instill false consciousness" mean to you? When I try to parse this sentence I get "make people incorrectly believe" maybe? I'm not clear on your meaning.

All in all, if I'm reading you correctly, you're saying that people are being tricked by a political party, yes? That being the case, it's definitely possible that you're right. I would suggest, however, that it appears much more likely that both major parties are playing that game.

I mean, I watched the last American president endure four years of accusations from his political rivals that he would start wars, persue extremist agendas, and be the destruction of his country. We were told that if he wasn't stopped, everything would go to hell in a handbasket. So he was stopped. Afterward, their candidate for presidency appears to be ushering his country to hell in a handbasket.

Seems like everyone is playing fast and loose with the truth anymore. I believe that's a pretty typical politician game.

Re:Liberal Hypocrisy Is Fueling American Inequality. Here’s ... by kcplate on Saturday November 13, 2021 @01:21AM (#29207867)
Interesting. I live in a very rural community in a neighborhood that is incredibly diverse, not only racially, but by age and religion too. We get along just fine.

Perhaps this area tends towards republicans because folks around here aren’t overly hung up about their differences and seem more to focus on their similarities. They also seem to be more capable of self-sufficiency and less day to day reliance on the government…even those with modest incomes. That tends to be the GOP messaging (at least around here) and people are drawn to it. Their life perspective tends to run counter to the dem messaging of division and government reliance.

We also have two different fiber optic ISPs willing to provide internet to our homes. I assure you there is definitely no lack of information around here.

Re:Liberal Hypocrisy Is Fueling American Inequality. Here’s ... by cipher_system on Friday November 12, 2021 @01:52AM (#29196924)
Could it be that the people in dense urban areas have more exposure to propaganda and more contact with political commissars, making it easier for Democrats to instill false consciousness by whipping up fear of the other.

Or should we maybe try to avoid this kind of toxic rhetoric all together.

Re:Liberal Hypocrisy Is Fueling American Inequality. Here’s ... by throwaway0a5e on Friday November 12, 2021 @06:44AM (#29198313)
It takes a record book worthy amount of tone deafness to suggest that the poorer parts of the republican base have been hoodwinked into spending generations voting for a party that promises to solve their problems but does nothing of the sort but the same part of the democratic base hasn't. The republicans have served poor rural voters no better or worse than the democrats have served poor inner city voters.
Re:Liberal Hypocrisy Is Fueling American Inequality. Here’s ... by kcplate on Saturday November 13, 2021 @01:35AM (#29207913)
For about the last 35 years (since Bush 41) I saw no discernible difference between the parties in terms of governance (lots of difference in rhetoric though). However, once the pandemic hit there tended to be a much greater amount of authoritarianism regarding pandemic policies coming from elected democrats. Interestingly it was across the board as well. Even down to the local community levels, it seemed to me that the democrats were interested in way more heavy handed approaches.

This seems to have now expanded beyond pandemic management to other things as well. That is a concern for me.

Re:Liberal Hypocrisy Is Fueling American Inequality. Here’s ... by dariusj18 on Friday November 12, 2021 @10:53AM (#29200528)
I don't think it's generations, just over the last 20 years. It was the inevitable long term effect of the Southern Strategy.
Re:Liberal Hypocrisy Is Fueling American Inequality. Here’s ... by LogonType10 on Friday November 12, 2021 @01:37AM (#29196846)
I know for a fact that the San Joaquin valley is more diverse than San Francisco.
Re:Liberal Hypocrisy Is Fueling American Inequality. Here’s ... by hindsightbias on Friday November 12, 2021 @02:21AM (#29197059)
And San Joaquin County went overwhelming for the liberals in 2020:

https://www.sjgov.org/WorkArea/DownloadAsset.aspx?id=33619

Perhaps you should look at demographics and voting patterns for your chosen sections of the valley.

[dead]
Re:Liberal Hypocrisy Is Fueling American Inequality. Here’s ... by dang on Saturday November 13, 2021 @02:54PM (#29212647)
Please don't post ideological flamewar comments to HN, or take HN threads further into flamewar generally. It's not what this site is for, and it destroys what is for.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

As for politics- there's no ban. The question of what's on topic vs. off topic is complex. I've posted many long explanations of this: https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&so.... Some links to start with, if you want to read more:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21607844

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22902490

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17014869

If anyone has a question that hasn't been answered there, I'd like to know what it is, and if you know a better way for HN to relate to political topics while fulfilling its mandate, I'd definitely like to know what it is. Just please familiarize yourself with the past explanations first, because if it's something simple like "just ban politics" or "just allow everything", I've answered many times already why it won't work.

Re:Liberal Hypocrisy Is Fueling American Inequality. Here’s ... by hagbard_c on Sunday November 14, 2021 @09:28AM (#29217358)
The proposal has been done before: add a "show/hide politics" option to the preferences, similar to the "show dead" option. Allow users to mark posts for being political, set this flag on a post once a threshold has been passed. Hide posts with the "politics" flag by default but do not shadowban users for political reasons - this ends up showing personal political bias and only worsens the problem. Users who do not mind political banter enable "show politics" in their preferences which makes these posts visible to them.

It is impossible to keep all politics out of the subject matter discussed on this site since there is a conscious effort to politicise everything, this is especially clear in "progressive" circles. Since it (for now) is also there where most tech development happens politics often come directly from the source.

Add the flag, allow users to mark posts and the problem is mostly solved - or at least it is out of sight for those who don't like these discussions and for those who visit the site without logging in. Trying to ban them altogether is futile since it nigh impossible to do without showing personal political bias.

Re:Liberal Hypocrisy Is Fueling American Inequality. Here’s ... by dang on Sunday November 14, 2021 @02:37PM (#29219906)
I'm pretty sure I haven't written about that idea in the past explanations I linked to, so you're at least right to ask about it, and I'm happy to address it now. In my view, it wouldn't work and would probably make things worse. Here's why.

There's no consensus about what is "political". The question "is X political or not" is just as hotly debated as the underlying political conflicts. Arguing about whether "X is political" quickly becomes a proxy for arguing about X itself. Most users won't bother with a "mark story as political' button, but you know who will? All the politically passionate users. In other words a "mark as political" button would simply become a new weapon for warring political sides to exploit in battle.

Worse, once a story got marked 'political' and removed from some feed, the side that lost—i.e. that didn't want it removed—would come back to HN to complain about that, repost the story, and generally try to fight the battle on other fronts. We don't need any of this.

Even the users who wanted politics removed from their feed would be unhappy because they would eventually find out that lots of stories which they actually wanted to see, had been removed for being 'political'. Maybe they still want to read about topics like technical interviewing, or end-to-end encryption? Well, a lot of people believe strongly that those are political topics—and they have a point, since at minimum there's some political overlap there. It's not at all obvious how/where to draw this line. All you'd get by adding up a bunch of different opinions about where to draw it would be a line that satisfied no one. It would feel crazy and arbitrary, too, like an image of a face made from bits of lots of different faces.

The idea is tempting because it comes from a false assumption. It's easy to imagine that the question "is X political" would be answered in a way that approximately corresponds to your own feelings about what counts as political. In reality, it wouldn't; how people answer that question is intensely personal and, as I've explained, already intensely political. It is an egg out of which the entire political arena would eventually re-hatch. It's not a way to solve or avoid the conflicts we already experience—we'd just end up with the same fires, but burning in more places.

Ultimately, I'd say this is a variant of the principle that you can't solve human issues with technical mechanisms. It's tempting to try, because technical mechanisms are easy to add and human issue are hard to solve. But after a while the same human issues will re-express themselves, like how water erodes and works around obstacles. There's no substitute for the hard human work of relating to each other.

There's another aspect that I think is relevant here. It's part of HN's DNA that it's a non-siloed site. That is, people don't choose what/who to follow. Unlike Reddit, Twitter, Facebook, etc.—which all have mechanisms by which users self-segregate into subgroups—on HN everybody sees the same feed. Whether we like it or not, we're all in one big room together. This leads to a lot of uncomfortable experiences because, much of the time, we don't like being in the same room with people we strongly disagree with. Nonetheless I think it would be a mistake to sacrifice this quality and subdivide HN into siloes. Every online community needs to deeply understand what it is and not try to be something else—trying to rewrite the DNA would likely turn HN into a poor version of some other kind of site, rather than being the best form of this that we can be.

I've written elsewhere about how important I think the non-siloed aspect of HN is, if anyone wants more:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23308098

https://hn.algolia.com/?query=silo%20by%3Adang&dateRange=all...