News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Nukemap by JasonFruit on Thursday November 11, 2021 @05:51PM (#29194277)
I would find it more reassuring if there were more evidence that countries are rational where war is concerned. A recently-concluded twenty-year war to remove and reinstate the Taliban is not encouraging.
Re:Nukemap by zamadatix on Thursday November 11, 2021 @06:20PM (#29194513)
However big a failure that war may seem using it for extrapolation in this case is like predicting a person wouldn't take risk of bankruptcy seriously because they lost a quarter in the couch cushions without getting worked up about it.

It's not even comparable with the impact of a single nuke let alone nuclear war.

Re:Nukemap by JasonFruit on Thursday November 11, 2021 @06:47PM (#29194754)
I understand economic impact is not the whole story, but the Japanese estimate of all economic losses due to the Hiroshima bombing was 884 million yen, about 1.2 trillion 2021 US dollars, by my calculations. The cost of the war in Pakistan and Afghanistan, which is all of a piece, was about 2.3 trillion USD. One was a $1.2 trillion atrocity; the other is a $2.3 trillion atrocity.

On another note, while Japan has recovered very well — thrived, even — after the impact of two nuclear weapons, the Soviet Union never did fully recover from its Afghanistan debacle, which was part of the background for its eventual collapse. Don't underestimate the undesirability of nuclear attacks or disastrous wars that can neither be won nor gained from.

Re:Nukemap by zamadatix on Thursday November 11, 2021 @07:45PM (#29195114)
> I understand economic impact is not the whole story, but the Japanese estimate of all economic losses due to the Hiroshima bombing

The bomb dropped on hiroshima was more than an magnitude smaller than a standard bomb these days.

> was 884 million yen, about 1.2 trillion 2021 US dollars, by my calculations.

~884 million yen at the time but that's a relatively meaningless number. A better measure would be 2% of economic wealth of Japan at the time which is where I assume you came up with the second number... for a 20kt fission type bomb dropped in a city of 350,000. A modern bomb 10x the size dropped on a modern city 10x the size is going to be measured in the 10s of trillions in costs - instantly for a single bomb, not part of a 20 year funding campaign that ends up recirculating a lot of money in the military industrial complex.

> On another note, while Japan has recovered very well — thrived, even — after the impact of two nuclear weapons

2 weapons totaling the 10th of a normal weapon at a time no other country had a nuclear weapon to retaliate with.

> the Soviet Union never did fully recover from its Afghanistan debacle, which was part of the background for its eventual collapse. Don't underestimate the undesirability of nuclear attacks or disastrous wars that can neither be won nor gained from.

Sure, plenty of things compounded have led to the downfall of countries over the last few thousand years. I can't however think of any reason or even set of reasons that would be comparable to millions of citizens dying overnight due to instantaneous deletion of a major population center... x100.

Re:Nukemap by JasonFruit on Thursday November 11, 2021 @09:10PM (#29195598)
Just look at those goalposts go. Whee!
Re:Nukemap by InGoodFaith on Friday November 12, 2021 @12:38AM (#29196598)
I understand your earlier point of military wars not exactly being rational - but:

Is it really moving the goalposts to say that comparing the economic impact spread over decades isn't the same as one experienced relatively instantaneously?

Or the risk of retaliation from a nuclear power isn't comparable to guerilla warfare?

Moving goalposts or not, it just doesn't seem to be an apt comparison to gauge military rationality.

Re:Nukemap by johncolanduoni on Friday November 12, 2021 @12:43AM (#29196615)
You’re the one who moved them the other direction by bringing up Hiroshima in relation to contemporary nuclear war where all weapons in play would be thermonuclear (and there would be more than two).
Re:Nukemap by LogonType10 on Friday November 12, 2021 @12:47AM (#29196634)
>countries aren't rational, because Taliban
Re:Nukemap by Teknoman117 on Thursday November 11, 2021 @07:06PM (#29194861)
You also have to realize that NATO invested tremendous amount of time and capital into the recovery of Japan and Germany following WW2. They didn't want a repeat of WW1 where the damage done to the defeated nations created a festering resentment and yet another war 20 years later.
Re:Nukemap by JasonFruit on Thursday November 11, 2021 @07:09PM (#29194882)
You're right that there were other factors at play. I'm just trying to point out that the two are not as incomparable to one another as they were being made out to be.
Re:Nukemap by tehjoker on Friday November 12, 2021 @02:23AM (#29197072)
It's unfortunate that wars are so often initially fought over domestic concerns (usually as a distraction from them) which makes disastrous war more likely because the logic of the foreign situation is less salient.