Re:Phil Zimmermann: Beware of Snake Oil Crypto (1997)
by caf on Tuesday August 23, 2011 @08:02PM
(#2918873)
I think AC is, like Zimmerman above, talking mostly about the data-at-rest case when it refers to key management being the riskiest part. This is reasonable, because in the data-at-rest case, all cryptography does is replace a large secret (the plaintext you want to protect) with a small secret (the key you need to protect instead). If you already had a keeping-something-a-secret problem, then it's reasonable to presume that you will have almost as much of a problem keeping the key a secret.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Phil Zimmermann: Beware of Snake Oil Crypto (1997)
by tptacek on Tuesday August 23, 2011 @08:05PM
(#2918877)
First, _Applied_ is totally not just talking about data at rest. It's chock full of archaic challenge-response protocols and half-specified descriptions of asy key exchange schemes.
Second, even for data at rest problems, _Applied_ is a terrible resource.
Just get _Practical Cryptography_ and burn your copy of _Applied_. Schneier co-authored _Practical_. It's a great book.
Re:Phil Zimmermann: Beware of Snake Oil Crypto (1997)
by caf on Tuesday August 23, 2011 @08:25PM
(#2918931)
Agreed - I have both already, I haven't burnt AC yet though (I find it occasionally useful for identifying which oddball 90s cipher a developer has gotten it into their head to use - yes, I have actually seen "3-Way" used in anger...)