News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:liblinux: Architecture-independent access to Linux system... by lelanthran on Thursday November 11, 2021 @05:37AM (#29186529)
> Linux lets you do this. The interface is stable. People can build their custom user space on top of it and enjoy a great kernel full of drivers. Wouldn't it be amazing if someone came up with a 100% Lisp user space? A 100% Rust user space?

Great indeed (I like Lisp!), but I have to question how useful that would be in practice.

Let's take Lisp as an example: I can now program only in Lisp and talk to the OS in native Lisp only (including POSIX calls). The downsides are that I cannot call any existing library; my 100% Lisp environment cannot use libzip, or libffmpeg/libavutil, or libSDL, etc.

In order to make that 100% Lisp environment actually useful it's going to be doing FFI calls anyway into a C ABI. That makes the OS-interface redundant.

Python is as popular as it is purely because it made calling into the C ABI easy: existing libraries were made instantly useful in Python, not unnecessarily hard.

There are no comments on this comment yet.