Re:Oracle's 'APIs are copyrightable' defense = nightmare for...
by timf on Tuesday August 23, 2011 @06:27PM
(#2918628)
Thanks for pointing that out. But law does sometimes conflict with how we wish things were or how things should just obviously work, and I don't pretend to know any better on the specifics (I certainly hope that there is indeed a precedent that protects abstract APIs from being copyrighted).
The guy did start the NoSoftwareParents campaign, so I don't know how much of an "Oracle shill" he could really be. Hard to really know, of course.
Re:Oracle's 'APIs are copyrightable' defense = nightmare for...
by joe_the_user on Tuesday August 23, 2011 @07:12PM
(#2918762)
Mueller is a lobbyist. IE, he has a long history of being to represent various positions not of which are necessarily consistent (he has represented coalitions of closed-source companies for example).
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Florian_M%C3%BCller
I'm not sure what is behind his current slant. However, I believe he created nosoftwareparents.com when he was working for MySQL. Oracle's acquisition of MySQL might be an explanation, here.
Our "professional corporate communicator" certainly spends a lot of effort looking at these cases but his role in publicizing a a variety of bogus claims such as the various "Android violates the GPL" efforts inclines me to count my fingers and neurons after I read his blog.