Would you make the same argument in favor of getting rid of upvotes?
Also, expressing disagreement isn't censorship. The availability of the content is unchanged. YouTube doesn't eliminate content from their platform based on some number of downvotes.
I enjoy 4chans model of posts with more replies generally attracting more attention (similar to sorting by controversial on Reddit). I also like that the dialogue graph there isn't necassarily 'tree shaped' and it's easier to reply to comments across a thread.
They grey it out because they don't show the count. They used to, back in the early days, and it just promoted stupid arguments.
Greying it out is an elegant solution that plays well with local culture where some people will provide corrective upvotes if they think the comment doesn't deserve that.
The most eggregious abuse on HN is flagging things that don't deserve it. Comments about inflation a few months ago were being flagged constantly or categorized as 'right-wing'. That's straight up censorship since the content disappears for most users who don't know the show-dead option in settings.
Flagging is great for spam and rude comments - I am down for that.
Agree across the board. Given that internet dialogue hugely influences our thoughts today, I think the importance of the tools, platforms and/or form used to discuss things is an underrated consideration. Especially with 'misinformation' or truth wars taking place today. I think that's gonna be one of the biggest problems that needs to be solved but no ones talking about it.
I would love to somehow live in a world where the information delivered to me and others was true and not misleading, only trying to accurately convey the info at hand, and not cherrypicking or manipulating. Essentially life without propaganda or lies. I don't want to spend life either sorting through propaganda to find obfuscated truth or simply accepting the dominant consensus. Sadly I don't know how someone could ever solve this without deciding who the (corruptible) arbiters of truth are. I wish we lived in a world where our individual incentives aligned with what brings out the best both ourselves and others. I have been getting sad lately feeling like there will always be a monopoly on truth and violence, a monopoly on reality, and it will never have our best interest at the center of its heart.
'Science' is seen as the answer, the ultimate objective arbiter of truth but sadly it's an abused buzzword and has become an authority figure with followers that obey its consensus. The scientific process is diametrically opposed to accepting consensus and is about falsifying hypothesis. Today studies are sponsored by corporations that have already defined what they want to conclude and this is accepted in the public sphere as a source of truth, despite the infamous 'replication crisis' also being known in the public sphere. How do you trust experts that don't trust themselves, or have incentives that work against you?
I just feel like I've lost all hope until I see a reasonable solution on the horizon.
>inb4 just buy chainlink
The value of the downvotes on HN, Reddit and YouTube is to save time when trying to find signal among the noise.
Still, I agree that some people may end up unfairly not being heard/seen.
But removing downvotes seem one step closer to surrendering to The Algortihm.
Then again, perhaps that is the general idea. And perhaps it will work out. YouTube can transparently use watch time instead of vote counts when deciding how to rank stuff. That’s what TikTok does, from what I understand. Maybe YouTube already does as wel. And in that sense, video content is a bit different from text.
So even though my initial impression of this change was negative, I think it may work out when we consider the difference between HN, Reddit on one side and video streaming services like YouTube and TikTok on the other side. (Also, I am aware that Reddit hosts videos too, but I am talking about the text and external link content here).
Second: You claim here that downvoting an opinion "censors" it. All I can say to that is, you need to look up "censor" in the dictionary.
Third: You are seriously arguing that moderation should be illegal? Please tell me that was a joke.
B) text selection
C) I think HN is one of the least ignorant communities out there on the net. Occasionally downvoted comments are merely controversial or against the grain, but more often then not, they are flawed in some way. In fact their rarity makes them neat to read (high surprisal) if only to understand where they might be coming from.
Please learn the difference and don't gaslight people about this.