“The racist denigration of the savage, and naive celebration of savage innocence, are always treated as two sides of the same imperialist coin.56 Yet originally this was an explicitly right-wing position, as explained by Ter Ellingson, the contemporary anthropologist who has reviewed the subject most comprehensively. Ellingson concluded there never was a ‘noble savage’ myth; at least not in the sense of a stereotype of simple societies living in an age of happy primordial innocence. Rather, travellers’ accounts tend to supply a much more ambivalent picture, describing alien societies as a complicated, sometimes (to them) incoherent, mix of virtues and vices. What needs to be investigated, instead, might better be called the ‘myth of the myth of the noble savage’: why is it that certain Europeans began attributing such a naive position to others?”
> The phrase later became identified with the idealized picture of "nature's gentleman", which was an aspect of 18th-century sentimentalism.
These days the sentiment seems more associated with people expressing unhappiness with complexity.
Perhaps they'd discover that their purported paradises were as friction-laden as the present, albeit without all the bad, bad technology that ehances our Tartaran present.
[1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Noble_savage