Re:The Surreal Horror of Pam
by notacoward on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @04:58PM
(#29168081)
Also things like "finger" looking up their home directory and showing you their .plan file. Not saying it was a good choice then, let alone now, but the number of Chesterton's Fence violations in this presentation is pretty high.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:The Surreal Horror of Pam
by lexicality on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @05:33PM
(#29168446)
> the number of Chesterton's Fence violations in this presentation is pretty high
The article's tagged as satire, I'm not sure you should be expecting good logic and sources
Re:The Surreal Horror of Pam
by notacoward on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @07:09PM
(#29169334)
Is there anything besides the tag to indicate that it's satire, in a sense that any teacher or student of writing would recognize? People have used "just kidding" as a way to duck criticism since time immemorial, but that doesn't mean we have to accept it unthinkingly.
> This is a partially satirical talk. It is intended to be mostly factually accurate, however some of the details are stretched for comedic effect.
I'd think this would cover all the bases. But what do I know, I just wrote the talk.
Re:The Surreal Horror of Pam
by notacoward on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @08:54PM
(#29170218)
Yes, you did, and it was a good talk. I actually did enjoy the snarky tone. PAM is a mess. On the other hand, I don't think that disclaimer really does cover all the bases. You yourself say it's partially satirical, implying that other parts are sincerely meant. Why shouldn't those be subject to the same discussion, correction, or even criticism as any other sincerely meant opinion in any other thing linked here? I'm pretty sure you can handle that back-and-forth better than Sir Lexicality gives you credit for.
And if anyone's still offended: my comments are partially satirical too. There, I'm immunized.
Re:The Surreal Horror of Pam
by butwhywhyoh on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @09:05PM
(#29170289)
This is the perfect cover to do whatever you want at all times.
I made an incorrect statement? Don't worry, I _meant_ to get that part wrong.
This part here that was insightful and you enjoyed? I meant that part 100%.
[dead]
Re:The Surreal Horror of Pam
by notacoward on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @09:31PM
(#29170415)
Hey, I'm supposed to be the Bad Guy here, and even I think that was uncalled for.
Re:The Surreal Horror of Pam
by dogecoinbase on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @11:59PM
(#29171239)
Play Devil's Advocate, and devils sometimes show up to be advocated for.
Re:The Surreal Horror of Pam
by shawn-butler on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @09:59PM
(#29170568)
Just giving clear non-satirical and honest feedback. The basic facts/history are incorrect. Not to mention the not-so implicit disrespect to the contributors (Sun, lolz! C modules oh-no omgz).
If I was watching this in a 30-second tiktok maybe I would have thought it was funny, or maybe the audience for the talk was expecting such low-grade content? Can't say I wasn't there.
On the other hand, if it hadn't been playful and glib about the decisions that led up to PAM as we know it, we might have had fewer of these lovely greybeards pop up to teach us some PAM and Unix history in the discussion :)
maybe Xe can address their comments in a followup, perhaps even after consulting with them a bit on the project itself