Re:Squid game: how we load-tested Ably’s Control API
by atanasb on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @05:36PM
(#29181904)
> To slow down or stop attacks, we limit requests made by a specific user / IP. [...] While that confirms that we can limit unauthorized and bad users who make too many requests, the testing failed because we also blocked the simulated good users on the same IP.
I don't understand the problem this is trying to solve.
In the test setup both good and malicious actors are simulated on the same IP address (which coincidentally might also be a real world situation).
So you're trying to load test - but failing because you get throttled/rate-limited - which is good.
But how does Squid help in this case - doesn't it just mask away the actual load by caching content?
In that case are you actually testing the ControlAPI load - or how good Squid's caching is?
Aside from that - pretty interesting read. Would live to see a bit more technical detail and depth for the next blog post!
Re:Squid game: how we load-tested Ably’s Control API
by Gys on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @12:34PM
(#29164629)
'squid game' meaning squid proxy is used in the test setup and 'game' is only in the title. maybe funny, but I think such clickbaity title is not helpful.
Re:Squid game: how we load-tested Ably’s Control API
by stichers on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @12:53PM
(#29164915)
It’s not unusual though. Most newspapers and magazines make punny headlines and captions to their graphics. Have you read the Economist? Their puns are exquisite and only add to the reading experience IMHO
Re:Squid game: how we load-tested Ably’s Control API
by mcny on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @02:32PM
(#29166316)
> drop me a line
Did you mean to add your email address to your profile?
Only admins see your email in the email input box. To share publicly, add to the 'about' box.
Here's a public view of your profile:
https://archive.fo/7RaXg
I don't understand the problem this is trying to solve. In the test setup both good and malicious actors are simulated on the same IP address (which coincidentally might also be a real world situation).
So you're trying to load test - but failing because you get throttled/rate-limited - which is good.
But how does Squid help in this case - doesn't it just mask away the actual load by caching content?
In that case are you actually testing the ControlAPI load - or how good Squid's caching is?
Aside from that - pretty interesting read. Would live to see a bit more technical detail and depth for the next blog post!
https://www.ladbible.com/funny/uk-viral-celebrity-cars-james...
I have a magical solution, and I'm looking for people to try it.
edit: thanks mcny, woops! On Gmail, I'm ebeland.
Did you mean to add your email address to your profile?
Only admins see your email in the email input box. To share publicly, add to the 'about' box. Here's a public view of your profile: https://archive.fo/7RaXg