News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why is Tcl syntax so weird (2013) by rightbyte on Monday November 08, 2021 @03:11PM (#29153636)
> The basic problem is, how do you even know that something is a variable reference?

Isn't that by convention? Like there is a "upvar" to grab values of the prior stack.

Re:Why is Tcl syntax so weird (2013) by int_19h on Monday November 08, 2021 @05:45PM (#29155285)
"upvar" is explicit, there's no guesswork involved there. But how would you handle a lambda with a body like this?

   if {$foo == 1} { puts $bar } else { puts $baz }
given that all the {}s are just non-expanded string literals, and what makes them be interpreted as code is the implementation of "if"? Sure, you can hardcode "if"; but the whole point of Tcl is that syntax constructs like that can be easily implemented as a library, which breaks if you have to special-case them in lambdas for them to work.

Now if you used upvar, this kinda sorta works, but only so long as the lambda is immediately invoked by the function that it was passed to. If you want to pass it on, you'd have to wrap it in another lambda. And, of course, this only works for lambdas that don't escape.