News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A great organic-food fraud by localhost on Monday November 08, 2021 @10:46AM (#29150446)
When I was a graduate student, a paper that I read while randomly reading stuff in the library really changed how I looked at things in this area - I found a copy here [1] and the DOI [2]. The author is Bruce Ames, creator of the "Ames Test" for carcinogenicity [3]

The core arguments in the paper are that plants don't exist to serve as food for us, they exist to reproduce. Plants grown in a stressful environment spend significant metabolic energy in generating chemical defenses against predators e.g., molds. Some of those chemical defenses are carcinogenic. Plants grown in less stressful (pesticide-controlled) environments generate less of those chemical defenses.

So, roughly synthetic == bad, natural == good.

Yes, this is a 1990 paper and perhaps it is no longer true and I'm certainly no expert in this area (I'm sad to see that a paper that influenced me so much at the time lacks significant citations).

  [1] https://files.toxplanet.com/cpdb/pdfs/Angew.pdf
  [2] DOI: 10.1002/anie.199011971
  [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bruce_Ames
Re:A great organic-food fraud by colechristensen on Monday November 08, 2021 @10:56AM (#29150576)
I entirely believe this but would add a couple of cautions.

One is that it likely goes both directions: there are likely stressors increased by both conventional and organic production (presumably different ones) Plant health is tied pretty closely with local ecology health and there is a lot of symbiosis going on.

Second is that you are not a weed or an insect or a fungus. Some plant defenses are quite enjoyed by humans (lots of drugs, caffeine, capsaicin, the flavors of most herbs).

It is the kind of thing where you can’t make a blanket generalization. You need specifics and weighed risks. An interesting opening theory but definitely not enough to base life choices on.