Re:Goodbye, shitty "Car extends Vehicle" object-orientation ...
by haberman on Monday August 22, 2011 @09:20PM
(#2914909)
It is pointless if you make it an ontological exercise. If you make it a question of substitutability (as your link does), then I agree that you're doing it the right way.
The question shouldn't be: "is a Square a special kind of Rectangle, in a pure/platonic/logical sense?" The question should be "can a Square be treated as if it were a Rectangle." The answer to the second question could depend on the program and what it wants to do! The first is a rathole that accomplishes nothing.
The question shouldn't be: "is a Square a special kind of Rectangle, in a pure/platonic/logical sense?" The question should be "can a Square be treated as if it were a Rectangle." The answer to the second question could depend on the program and what it wants to do! The first is a rathole that accomplishes nothing.