Re:MLAT order from Luxembourg for Signal user data
by hippich on Monday November 08, 2021 @04:38AM
(#29147596)
Last time I tried them, they still required phone number? If it is still the case, they did compromise on the users privacy.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:MLAT order from Luxembourg for Signal user data
by usui on Monday November 08, 2021 @04:49AM
(#29147651)
This is a usability stance. Removing the ability to use phone numbers would have made it harder for users to adopt Signal, and I find it to be a reasonable trade-off. At least right now, the only thing prying eyes can do is know that you use Signal due to the login SMS, or hijack your SMS. We all know about some terrible security practices that phone providers have been doing with phone number swapping by unauthorized parties, but if we can pick non-awful phone providers which at least have password-protected SIM locks on the account, it shouldn't be as viable.
Re:MLAT order from Luxembourg for Signal user data
by JoshTriplett on Monday November 08, 2021 @06:00AM
(#29148065)
> Removing the ability to use phone numbers
I've never seen anyone ask for Signal to remove the ability to use phone numbers. People ask Signal to add the ability to use something other than a phone number, as well.
Re:MLAT order from Luxembourg for Signal user data
by Arnt on Monday November 08, 2021 @07:30AM
(#29148619)
As I've heard it, it's motivated by security rather than usability: If two people use Signal to communicate with each other, then they should use the Signal protocol rather than SMS, without having to go through any extra steps.
There are different ways to achieve that, all of which have drawbacks. They chose one.