News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The intellectual incoherence of cryptoassets by wallacoloo on Sunday November 07, 2021 @03:34PM (#29143254)
I appreciate the author sharing his views, especially because he does a good job of distilling them. If cryptocurrencies are truly novel, however, it's not clear that one should be able to draw a direct analogy to an existing product. That they don't 100% resemble money, or commodities, or stock, or art, isn't necessarily a problem.

My argument for owning Eth is that it's like buying real estate (yes, I'm making another loose analogy). Why does a person invest in land? Because they expect something to flourish in the vicinity of their land, and they'll be able to capture some of that increased productivity in the form of rent (or appreciation).

Ethereum is a programmable ledger, and Eth is its unit of capital. A programmable ledger is a tool that can be used to create things like a money supply the author describes. The next question here is "why would someone prefer to use an analogous system created on Ethereum over whatever exists today" and that answer can be some combination of transparency, usability, and legitimacy. If we want something like the elastic-supply currency the author describes, we can create one for ourselves. We can do so without providing limitless power to a centralized authority (i.e. the Fed). To some, the resulting currency will be more legitimate as a result. (checkout Rai or Liquity for examples of elastic/"algorithmic" stablecoins on Ethereum).

In this view, today's value of Eth is largely speculative. On the other hand, this gives a way to fund development. New protocols like the ones I mentioned are able to capture the value they create only because there's already so much $ in this ecosystem, and that money's eager to pay a 0.1% fee for the benefit of this new product.

There's a lot of circular activity going on, sure. Deflationary rewards, leverage, etc. If you haven't seen an 80% drop in crypto yet, be ready for it (seriously). But as long as the influx in capital facilitates some level of actual new products -- as it does appear to me to be doing -- then what really is the issue here? Maybe we can be satisfied in viewing it as a rather complicated machine for capital allocation? My biggest worry is that impending 80% drop: crypto is notorious for its volatility, but still each bull run draws in newcomers who think we're past all the drops and find themselves surprised when they lose 80%.

Re:The intellectual incoherence of cryptoassets by alphabettsy on Sunday November 07, 2021 @08:27PM (#29145311)
> Why does a person invest in land? Because they expect something to flourish in the vicinity of their land, and they'll be able to capture some of that increased productivity in the form of rent (or appreciation).

Most people buying land are not doing it as a speculative investment. There are many who buy real estate as an investment, but most people buy real estate for personal use. Even those who buy real estate as an investment they typically make money from improvements whether that’s farming or residential.

Re:The intellectual incoherence of cryptoassets by thebean11 on Sunday November 07, 2021 @09:15PM (#29145561)
Maybe they wouldn’t articulate it as speculation but that’s still what they are doing (even if they are living in the property). They are speculating that the value will not decrease, or that rents will increase. Otherwise they’d rent.

ETH does have a return currently of ~5% through staking.

Re:The intellectual incoherence of cryptoassets by alphabettsy on Monday November 08, 2021 @02:54AM (#29146963)
People living in the property are almost always buying it as both a place to live and as an investment.

Investment is not the same as speculation.

Even without guaranteed appreciation in value people will buy homes because they have an asset compared to alternatives like renting. When renting you’re guaranteed a loss on rent paid.

Re:The intellectual incoherence of cryptoassets by kangnkodos on Monday November 08, 2021 @02:29PM (#29153191)
I expect my property, my house and yard, to appreciate less than the S&P 500. I expect the value of my property to go up a little, but not a lot. By choosing to buy property, instead of living in the cheapest rental I could find, there is an opportunity cost. And I'm OK with that.

If money was the only goal, renting something extremely inexpensive and investing would give me a better financial return.

Re:The intellectual incoherence of cryptoassets by thebean11 on Monday November 08, 2021 @03:39AM (#29147258)
It's all relative. If home prices drop while you're renting that's a huge gain relative to owning property.
Re:The intellectual incoherence of cryptoassets by alphabettsy on Monday November 08, 2021 @01:40PM (#29152613)
You’re right that it’s all relative, but that’s not necessarily true.

Where I live buying is much cheaper than renting and even if my home is worth 25% less than I paid for it by the time it’s paid off I can come out ahead because I still have an asset worth let’s say $100k and I’ve spent less money than I would renting. That’s without factoring in the other reasons people buy homes.

Re:The intellectual incoherence of cryptoassets by thebean11 on Monday November 08, 2021 @05:01PM (#29154823)
If your home is down 25% isn’t all or most of your equity “gone” anyway? Guess it depends how slowly, but if it happens immediately you basically lost your entire down payment
Re:The intellectual incoherence of cryptoassets by motioncuty on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @12:24PM (#29164496)
Thats just homes, there are tons of other property classes outside of personal residential.
Re:The intellectual incoherence of cryptoassets by nybble41 on Monday November 08, 2021 @02:07PM (#29152955)
> They are speculating that the value will not decrease, or that rents will increase. Otherwise they’d rent.

That assumes you're getting the same product, but when renting you don't necessarily have any guarantee that the lease will be renewed when your rental term is up. Owning your own home is a more stable arrangement since you generally face no risk of eviction as long as you keep up with any applicable mortgage and property tax payments (barring exceptional circumstances such as eminent domain).

If you expect to move frequently then it might come down to just rent vs. mortgage and property value, but if you intend to stay in one place for the long term then ownership has other advantages to offer.

Re:The intellectual incoherence of cryptoassets by thebean11 on Monday November 08, 2021 @06:13PM (#29155579)
> you don't necessarily have any guarantee that the lease will be renewed when your rental term is up

Yep, that's exactly my point. It cuts both ways because your landlord also has no such guarantee; if prices decrease then the commitment is a liability not an asset. It just depends on the situation.

Re:The intellectual incoherence of cryptoassets by tata71 on Monday November 08, 2021 @04:51AM (#29147665)
Disagree.

Most people wouldn't pay the exorbitant interest, taxes, mortgage paper fees if they didn't think they'd get appreciation on the property — "like always!".

Re:The intellectual incoherence of cryptoassets by rsj_hn on Monday November 08, 2021 @04:53AM (#29147676)
They don't need to get appreciation, they just need to have the home be less costly than renting. Once you throw in the mortgage interest deduction that's a pretty low bar.
Re:The intellectual incoherence of cryptoassets by jfengel on Monday November 08, 2021 @12:49PM (#29151981)
The old joke is that you invest in land because they're not making it any more.

That's not the case with cryptocurrencies. Not just that they're still mining them, but that new cryptocurrencies are invented every day. You can hold a unique hold on a land, because there's only so much of it, but you can clone Etherium in a heartbeat. Or design your own that works better for something.

The hope is that one of these blockchains will get so many people behind it that it becomes the natural monopoly of whatever blockchain is good for, and then the money you spent mining/investing won't be wasted. You'll get network effects, a la Facebook -- everybody wants to be in the same place. But I don't see anybody really wanting to get behind giving money to those who got there first, not when they can make up their own.