Re:Windows 8: Building robust USB 3.0 support
by kazuya on Tuesday August 23, 2011 @01:16AM
(#2915441)
This article is not actually about USB. Neither about Windows 8.
What's interesting is that Microsoft uses model checking on real shipping products. In fact it has been pushing static checker (SLAM and SDV) for years.
Other operating systems including Linux have their own verification projects, but they all appear to stay academic (though look promising).
We can expect more reliable operating systems in this decade. Maybe.
Re:Windows 8: Building robust USB 3.0 support
by justincormack on Monday August 22, 2011 @05:11PM
(#2914140)
Actually looking foward to USB 3, not the speed but the fact there is command queuing for usb storage, which makes ssd performant (without queuing you get far fewer iops, factor of about 10 from memory)
Re:Windows 8: Building robust USB 3.0 support
by megrimlock on Monday August 22, 2011 @06:17PM
(#2914369)
Command queueing allows the device controller to handle requests out of order. Since it has intimate knowledge of the hardware it can order requests for maximum throughput.
Re:Windows 8: Building robust USB 3.0 support
by justincormack on Monday August 22, 2011 @06:37PM
(#2914440)
Actually a USB bus doesnt know much about the hardware, but can forward multiple simultaneous (SCSI) requests and if the hardware is fast it can deal with them in whatever order it wants.
If you benchmark an SSD with and without queueing you get very different speeds; with hard drives there is still a difference, although not as much.
Re:Windows 8: Building robust USB 3.0 support
by kenjackson on Monday August 22, 2011 @07:30PM
(#2914621)
USB 3.0 is cool and all, but I'm not sure I'd start the Win8 engineering discussion there. With that said, it's probably a cool feature that doesn't require showing off any new UI.
Re:Windows 8: Building robust USB 3.0 support
by watmough on Monday August 22, 2011 @04:56PM
(#2914081)
This is starting to look like a move to have engineers promoting various aspects of Windows 8. Great stuff, and I hope it keeps up.
These two videos make me feel like I want a copy of Windows around again. In particular, the showing multiple apps on screen, the way that was done just seems right, and pretty much the way I hoped the iPad would work, but sadly no.
Re:Windows 8: Building robust USB 3.0 support
by drv on Monday August 22, 2011 @05:12PM
(#2914144)
I found the part about designing the system with flowcharts in Visio and generating code based on the flowcharts, and apparently the model is validated based on the flowcharts as well.
Re:Windows 8: Building robust USB 3.0 support
by runjake on Monday August 22, 2011 @07:51PM
(#2914688)
In this context, "native support" means built into the OS as shipped.
As with most emerging technologies, thinks tend to show up as 3rd party drivers first and are later integrated into the next shipping Windows version or major service pack.
Typically, a USB 3.0 device would ship with a driver, or the OS would pull it off of Windows Update for Windows 7.
Re:Windows 8: Building robust USB 3.0 support
by daeken on Monday August 22, 2011 @08:28PM
(#2914773)
Yes, yes you can. Robustness isn't determined by auditing -- we know this doesn't work in practice. Robustness is determined by beating on it and seeing how it breaks; this is the point of heavy testing, including fuzzing in the case of drivers. You absolutely don't need source for this.
Re:Windows 8: Building robust USB 3.0 support
by hamidpalo on Monday August 22, 2011 @07:27PM
(#2914609)
Single person testing on a single prototype device vs a team testing on a custom-built test device that was designed after going through and capturing the behaviors of many devices.
Guess which one will work better with a wider range of devices?
What's interesting is that Microsoft uses model checking on real shipping products. In fact it has been pushing static checker (SLAM and SDV) for years.
Other operating systems including Linux have their own verification projects, but they all appear to stay academic (though look promising).
We can expect more reliable operating systems in this decade. Maybe.
If you benchmark an SSD with and without queueing you get very different speeds; with hard drives there is still a difference, although not as much.
EDIT benchmarks (Intel SSD)
no queuing, 4k reads: 3965 iops depth 4 , 4k reads: 16,900 iops depth 8, 4k reads: 25,700 iops depth 16, 4k reads: 32,600 iops depth 32, 4k reads: 38,800 iops
The benefit decreases with larger reads, but still exists.
These two videos make me feel like I want a copy of Windows around again. In particular, the showing multiple apps on screen, the way that was done just seems right, and pretty much the way I hoped the iPad would work, but sadly no.
http://kernelnewbies.org/Linux_2_6_31#head-2c74ce6091fb2feb4...
-edit- A quick google also leaves the impression that Windows support for USB 3 is new.
http://www.google.com/search?q=windows+usb+3+support
As with most emerging technologies, thinks tend to show up as 3rd party drivers first and are later integrated into the next shipping Windows version or major service pack.
Typically, a USB 3.0 device would ship with a driver, or the OS would pull it off of Windows Update for Windows 7.
dramatic responses are entertaining... but really guys wtf?
Guess which one will work better with a wider range of devices?