News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Show HN: My wife is pregnant; naturally I made a baby-nam... by thatwasunusual on Friday November 05, 2021 @10:15AM (#29119564)
This. Please don't create apps that shouldn't be apps.
Re:Show HN: My wife is pregnant; naturally I made a baby-nam... by williamdclt on Friday November 05, 2021 @10:21AM (#29119657)
Please do whatever the hell you want. There's a difference between asking a question, making a suggestion and shoving ideals down somebody's throat.
Re:Show HN: My wife is pregnant; naturally I made a baby-nam... by thatwasunusual on Saturday November 06, 2021 @03:42PM (#29133211)
> Please do whatever the hell you want.

Indeed. Especially if you want to piss off potensial users/customers.

> There's a difference between asking a question, making a suggestion and shoving ideals down somebody's throat.

Unfortunately, the "ideal" for many is to have an app for their - well - app, or service, whatever it might be. Usually it's just a perfectly functioning responsive web service that is turned to a native app instead of just going for a hybrid app (at least to start with).

In this specific case, there's is _absolutely no reason_ it should be provided as an app, at least not a native one.

Because:

The user already has everything installed on his phone to use the service; a browser.

To me, _as a (potential) user_, having to install this app would have been showing something down my throat. To solve that problem, the developer could have created it as a responsive web application first, and maybe made an hybrid app, and then decided if it is worthwhile creating a native app.

Why the desparate need to create native apps and have to maintain two totally different projects when there's no need to?

Re:Show HN: My wife is pregnant; naturally I made a baby-nam... by williamdclt on Saturday November 06, 2021 @06:06PM (#29134245)
All your arguments hold if this was something the developper was trying to grow (commercially or not). Given this is clearly just an app made for their own use and scratch an itch... Taking about pleasing potential users/customers and how you'd have to be forced to install this app is more or less off-topic.
Re:Show HN: My wife is pregnant; naturally I made a baby-nam... by thatwasunusual on Sunday November 07, 2021 @10:21AM (#29140155)
> Taking about pleasing potential users/customers and how you'd have to be forced to install this app is more or less off-topic.

Then why make an app out of something that would work just as well with something I have already installed on my phone?

Re:Show HN: My wife is pregnant; naturally I made a baby-nam... by heyoni on Saturday November 06, 2021 @04:12PM (#29133428)
Well, it was done in flutter so a web app might be something easy to do from that.
Re:Show HN: My wife is pregnant; naturally I made a baby-nam... by ARandomerDude on Friday November 05, 2021 @10:27AM (#29119737)
But how do you know if it should be an app? It seems like we need a ShouldThisBeAnApp app where you can upload screenshots, descriptions, API diagrams, etc. and allow AI + community input to make the determination.
Re:Show HN: My wife is pregnant; naturally I made a baby-nam... by thatwasunusual on Saturday November 06, 2021 @03:44PM (#29133220)
> But how do you know if it should be an app?

In this case it's very easy: if all the functionality can be run in the browser, which already is an app installed on my computer, don't make it an app. At least not a native one.

Re:Show HN: My wife is pregnant; naturally I made a baby-nam... by GuardianCaveman on Friday November 05, 2021 @10:34AM (#29119842)
No more apps! Only websites!
Re:Show HN: My wife is pregnant; naturally I made a baby-nam... by necovek on Friday November 05, 2021 @10:50AM (#29120091)
There should be a ShouldThisBeAnApp website, and a ShouldThisBeAWebsite app :D
Re:Show HN: My wife is pregnant; naturally I made a baby-nam... by fileeditview on Friday November 05, 2021 @10:58AM (#29120204)
Make it a ShouldThisBeAMobileAppOrWebAppOrNativeApp service that has a native implementation on all these platforms.
Re:Show HN: My wife is pregnant; naturally I made a baby-nam... by kingcharles on Friday November 05, 2021 @11:53AM (#29121040)
What if you don't want an app and you just want to consume an API? I'm thinking a better name would be ShouldThisBeAMobileAppOrWebAppOrNativeAppOrAWebService.
Re:Show HN: My wife is pregnant; naturally I made a baby-nam... by Tempest1981 on Friday November 05, 2021 @11:02AM (#29120262)
We'll see how this comment ages, in the VR meta future
Re:Show HN: My wife is pregnant; naturally I made a baby-nam... by pjbeam on Friday November 05, 2021 @01:12PM (#29122084)
Don't use apps you think shouldn't be apps? Making normative statements about something OP did for fun and shared with us is a bit odd.
Re:Show HN: My wife is pregnant; naturally I made a baby-nam... by thatwasunusual on Saturday November 06, 2021 @04:02PM (#29133364)
> Don't use apps you think shouldn't be apps?

I said: don't _create_ apps that shouldn't be apps.