Re:Language is The Scaffold of The Mind (2019)
by fourtrees on Saturday November 06, 2021 @08:05AM
(#29129502)
I'm not sure exactly what constitutes a 'severe language impairment'; there are lots of aphasias out there that only affect very specific parts of the whole language/writing system in the brain. They could be comprehend normally, but have trouble producing (on some level) speech or vice versa. If could comprehend spoken language without difficult, they could 'easily' complete tasks that didn't require those neural connections. Without knowing what the specific symptoms were, this is kind of a moot point.
Re:Language is The Scaffold of The Mind (2019)
by inter_netuser on Friday November 05, 2021 @03:05AM
(#29116216)
Nearly all of such studies are on stroke/trauma victims.
What weirds me out is that they completely disregard that no stroke/trauma victims are identical, but I guess they try their best to derive some insights on this rather heterogenous population.
These are hard experiments to run. I fear that as soon as we figure out how dolphins speak we are going to run such gruesome experiments, only intentional and controlled, on intelligent life.
Ok something is weird here. How were they *asked* to do these things if they have no language skills. Is the author brushing over the fact that they still had language skills, but they were not as good as they used to be? In which case all her conclusions about what we can do without any language skills are irrelevant as they don't apply, which would explain why she brushes over this point, I guess.