News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Do you really need a tablet? by ChuckMcM on Sunday August 21, 2011 @08:08PM (#2910706)
I find these sorts of editorials fascinating, basically they are "I don't see a need for this, my friend/spouse/other also doesn't see a need for it, therefore there is no good reason for these things to exist." As if the entire world was defined by the standard of the author.

A really good example is this comment in the article: "Pixel-for-pixel, I can see almost as much information in the palm of my hand as I can with an unwieldy screen that requires two hands to use with any precision whatsoever."

Here the author has no trouble at all reading the same text on a their iPhone that they have on their iPad. They are in for a rude surprise when they hit their mid-40s and their eyes start losing their current flexibility :-). Unless you want to look really dorky holding your iPhone three inches from your eyes, you will really appreciate that the larger screen makes things 'bigger' without having to zoom and give up those pixels.

That being said, the author misses that it is easier to read with a tablet than it is with a laptop because the keyboard is in the way and not essential to the task. And yes, when you want a keyboard, not having one sucks, but there are many applications where having a keyboard is actually broken.

For example, sign-in/sign-off sheets. You've got a bunch of people who are coming to your conference/meeting/facility and you have them on a list. Looking them up on a list, checking them off, and even entering the time/date when the arrived it hugely more productive with a tablet than it is either with a laptop or a pad of names. Many sort of form processes get similar benefits (inventory, quality sorting, Etc.) It can be an awesome calculator/adding machine (much better than a PC) because you can customize the key layout to your particular needs. Consuming information can be easier, and its a huge win if you want to show snapshots to your friends from your camera.

If the author had any sense of history they would look up the sage advice about how useless it was to put all of these 'smart' features on a phone, all you needed was for it to call numbers, and ring when called. The rest was just fluff.

Now, not so much.

There are no comments on this comment yet.