News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Facebook plans to shut down its facial recognition system by ryandrake on Tuesday November 02, 2021 @01:49PM (#29084813)
The privacy cat is already out of the bag once someone uploads a photo of you without your consent. That's the root behavior that should be corrected, and it's hard because the onus is on the privacy-conscious user, to get everyone else's cooperation. The facial recognition just adds even more privacy-questionable metadata.

My dream facial recognition feature for Facebook would be to allow me, as a non-user of Facebook, to upload some hash of my face and direct Facebook to disallow any user from uploading a picture with my face in it.

Re:Facebook plans to shut down its facial recognition system by skybrian on Tuesday November 02, 2021 @02:03PM (#29085069)
That's kind of a radical position. People shouldn't take photos of crowds in public places? You want veto power over that?
Re:Facebook plans to shut down its facial recognition system by marwis on Tuesday November 02, 2021 @04:33PM (#29086986)
Not radical enough. It should be an opt-in rather opt-out. A public website should verify that every person on the photo consented to being publicly displayed. Otherwise their faces should be pixelated.

I can certainly see things going that way in EU within a decade.

Re:Facebook plans to shut down its facial recognition system by jrochkind1 on Tuesday November 02, 2021 @08:09PM (#29089365)
I don't want every public website (and who else?) to have access to the perceptual hash of my face to identify it in uploaded pictures to ask me for opt-in.
Re:Facebook plans to shut down its facial recognition system by Vrondi on Tuesday November 02, 2021 @02:07PM (#29085121)
In the USA at least, there is no legal expectation of privacy on a public street. So, for news reporting purposes, you can publish photos of a crowd in public. However, as soon as you step onto private property, this changes. Even at places like shopping malls and stores, the owner of that place can take your photo for security, but cannot publish it, and it is not kosher for photographers to take photos of customers in these settings and publish them without getting a signed model release form the subject of the photo. Likewise, a photographer should get explicit permission for any other private spaces such as homes.
Re:Facebook plans to shut down its facial recognition system by reaperducer on Tuesday November 02, 2021 @04:33PM (#29086988)
However, as soon as you step onto private property, this changes. Even at places like shopping malls and stores, the owner of that place can take your photo for security, but cannot publish it, and it is not kosher for photographers to take photos of customers in these settings and publish them without getting a signed model release form the subject of the photo.

You're on the right track, but it's somewhat more complicated than that. There are plenty of times when you can be on private property and it's perfectly legal for someone to publish your photo.

Two companies I've worked for have brought in lawyers for staff training on this. It's nuanced.

Re:Facebook plans to shut down its facial recognition system by KennyBlanken on Wednesday November 03, 2021 @02:01AM (#29091521)
> In the USA at least, there is no legal expectation of privacy on a public street.

Depends on the state. In Massachusetts, for example, expectation of privacy doesn't matter. What matters is whether the recording was secret or not. Note that "secret" doesn't mean "the subject knew", it means "the subject could have known." If you're walking around with a zoom lens and a camera taking pictures of someone a block away who has no idea? Not secret. If you're in front of me with a camera hidden in your tie pin? Secret.

Security camera on the side of the building? Not secret. Security camera hidden on the side of the building made to look like a bird's nest? Secret.

> So, for news reporting purposes, you can publish photos of a crowd in public.

There's generally much wider latitude for use of a person's image in relation to press coverage of a newsworthy event.

> However, as soon as you step onto private property, this changes.

Not in Massachusetts, where secretly recording someone is illegal, period.

> it is not kosher for photographers to take photos of customers in these settings and publish them without getting a signed model release form the subject of the photo

Publishing is not a very relevant term. People have a right to control "commercial use" of their image.

Re:Facebook plans to shut down its facial recognition system by lossolo on Tuesday November 02, 2021 @08:31PM (#29089569)
You could just cut out the face from the picture.
Re:Facebook plans to shut down its facial recognition system by jdavis703 on Tuesday November 02, 2021 @02:40PM (#29085616)
In theory one could build a perceptual hash that had a universal opt-in. But I’m skeptical such a scheme could avoid collisions (e.g. identical twins) or perhaps even doppelgänger-like strangers.
Re:Facebook plans to shut down its facial recognition system by AuthorizedCust on Tuesday November 02, 2021 @02:27PM (#29085420)
Not exactly. From the perspective of building data of concern, simply uploading photos won't do that. Uploading photos just potentially creates databases of rando faces.

It is the tying of these faces to a name (identity) that's the challenge. Further, the crucial data comes from a human's act of tagging a person in a photo.

Re:Facebook plans to shut down its facial recognition system by MrKristopher on Tuesday November 02, 2021 @03:42PM (#29086452)
Is facial recognition so good that it can distinguish you from a billion other people? I assumed the photo recognition relied on the social graph i.e. to look for your friends or friends of friends in your pictures.
Re:Facebook plans to shut down its facial recognition system by 8note on Tuesday November 02, 2021 @02:06PM (#29085104)
the privacy has been broken once you've been photographed without your consent.

The same features for name association can be done offline once the picture exists. Just show people the picture, and see if anyone knows who it is

Re:Facebook plans to shut down its facial recognition system by mechanical_bear on Tuesday November 02, 2021 @02:40PM (#29085623)
Consent is not required in a public setting.