Re:Nymwars: A view from the trenches within Google
by InclinedPlane on Sunday August 21, 2011 @04:30AM
(#2908779)
The worst part is that google+ does support pseudonyms... if you're rich or famous enough. Personally I thought google was better than that.
Re:Nymwars: A view from the trenches within Google
by starwed on Sunday August 21, 2011 @05:28AM
(#2908834)
That's not what OP means... Your point is that google allows famous folk to use their RL pseudonym as their primary ID on google+.
What thristian means is that the system itself needs to allow a single account to present multiple nyms, depending on context.
Re:Nymwars: A view from the trenches within Google
by InclinedPlane on Sunday August 21, 2011 @12:45PM
(#2909540)
That's only part of the problem. The core problem is that google doesn't allow pseudonyms at all (even a single pseudonym across all circles) unless you happen to be famous enough, regardless of legal identity. It's a double standard.
Re:Nymwars: A view from the trenches within Google
by Aglet on Sunday August 21, 2011 @02:36AM
(#2908661)
Are you saying that everything cannot be losslessly converted to ASCII?
Re:Nymwars: A view from the trenches within Google
by thristian on Sunday August 21, 2011 @02:46AM
(#2908676)
You might claim that everything can be losslessly converted to ASCII by applying, say, base64, but I would claim what you lose in that situation is readability.
When I wrote that, I was mostly thinking about systems that assume it is always safe to replace "é" with "e", for example.
"nymwars" is a big complicated thing that has far outgrown my ability to keep track of the nuances, so I don't understand what this means for my personal pet feature (showing different names to different people), but it's encouraging to hear that there is raucous debate inside Google.
I still think that the strongest argument for pseudonyms is that a system that doesn't handle them is Wrong, in the same way that "everything can be losslessly converted to ASCII" is wrong, or "an accurate map of a geographical area can be drawn on a flat surface" is wrong. Pseudonyms aren't a feature you can decide whether to support or not, they're part of the problem that you're trying to solve.