Re:When “Foundation” Gets the Blockbuster Treatment, Asimov’...
by dkonofalski on Tuesday November 02, 2021 @11:19AM
(#29082533)
That's interesting to me because the brothers are one of my favorite parts of the show because of the new ideas they bring up in relation to the Empire. It gives the writers some really clever and interesting ways to discuss the problems with a long-standing continuity of ideas while giving those internal inconsistencies human faces to stand-in for something that would be much more nebulous and vague otherwise.
Re:When “Foundation” Gets the Blockbuster Treatment, Asimov’...
by rsynnott on Tuesday November 02, 2021 @11:24AM
(#29082618)
I feel like it kind of misses the point, though. Societies like that don't collapse because the leader is immortal, they do so because the _society_ is ossified.
Re:When “Foundation” Gets the Blockbuster Treatment, Asimov’...
by dkonofalski on Tuesday November 02, 2021 @11:38AM
(#29082861)
I don't even think that's the point, though. I think it's more of a criticism of strict stubbornness. It's not the fact that he's immortal that's the problem, it's the fact that he/they continue to "lead" in the exact same manner, attempting to ossify a society that, on its insides, is changing. The only thing consistent is change, especially in society. Isn't the point of Foundation that, despite spectacular individuals, societies move on and change?
Re:When “Foundation” Gets the Blockbuster Treatment, Asimov’...
by phh on Tuesday November 02, 2021 @11:44AM
(#29082948)
I feel it's the point they are trying to make with the cloned leader (I wouldn't exactly say immortal). They are saying the fall is faster because of an ossified leader, but nonetheless the fall will happen anyway, because it's not just the leader that is ossified, but the whole society.
Re:When “Foundation” Gets the Blockbuster Treatment, Asimov’...
by ASalazarMX on Tuesday November 02, 2021 @02:54PM
(#29085824)
> the clone emperor thing feels like a pointless overcomplication
This and other adaptations were made to keep the same actors for the thousand years of chaos. Some were ludicrous, like Gaal being forcefully put in hibernation for 30+ years, but the Cleon clones idea was well done in my opinion. It transmits that Cleon is the Empire. If only their interactions took less screen time...
I'm mostly quite enjoying it, but I think they could have been a _bit_ more restrained with their rewriting and lost nothing.
> everyone is smoking all the time, the hyper focus on nuclear power, the relative role of women
Also, newspapers! The original novels had paper newspapers, transmitted across the stars. At a certain age, science fiction tends to become accidentally a bit steampunk.