Re:Martin Ford Asks: Will Automation Lead to Economic Collapse?
by zeteo on Saturday August 20, 2011 @07:17PM
(#2908013)
>Your reply misses the point.
No it doesn't. Capital becomes obsolescent, labor does not.
>What happens when we develop technology which can do 99% of what a human can do better, faster, and cheaper?
During 99% of recorded history, agricultural labor was the prevailing definition of "what a human can do".
Re:Martin Ford Asks: Will Automation Lead to Economic Collapse?
by Zaak on Saturday August 20, 2011 @07:42PM
(#2908065)
Labor has not yet become obsolete. That doesn't mean it can't.
I'm not talking about the prevailing definition of what a human can do. I'm talking about the actual fact of what a human can do.
You still haven't addressed the question of what will happen when nearly everything which a human being is capable of can be done better by a machine.
Re:Martin Ford Asks: Will Automation Lead to Economic Collapse?
by zeteo on Saturday August 20, 2011 @08:13PM
(#2908118)
Labor does not become obsolete. Inefficient capital is discarded, but less efficient labor is always useful to some degree, because of comparative advantage (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comparative_advantage#Example_1).
This holds even for the scenario of AI becoming a very close substitute for humans. The economic pressure, however, is to develop AI in directions that are complementary to human abilities.
What happens when we develop technology which can do 99% of what a human can do better, faster, and cheaper?
With previous innovations, there was always something else that a displaced human worker could find to do. What happens when 99% of human jobs are gone?