News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Which is not Posix by jabl on Monday November 01, 2021 @02:19PM (#29070695)
As the Debian brouahaha pointed out, there are multiple incompatible implementations of which, so it's unclear which one (ha ha) POSIX should standardize on (and is it politically realistic to anoint one as the 'winner'?).

As for systemd, AFAIK system startup isn't covered by POSIX at all, so bsd init, sysv init and systemd are all equally not covered by POSIX. Which is fine, POSIX was never meant to cover every single behavior of an OS, but rather a sort of least common denominator to make porting easier (not "make porting non-existent").

Re:Which is not Posix by msbarnett on Monday November 01, 2021 @02:44PM (#29071048)
> As the Debian brouahaha pointed out, there are multiple incompatible implementations of which, so it's unclear which one (ha ha) POSIX should standardize on (and is it politically realistic to anoint one as the 'winner'?).

It's meaningless that there's no clear version that POSIX should standardize on – GNU `which` is the de facto standard on Linux. Debian is hardly going to ship FreeBSD's `which`, as even the discontinued Debian-on-FreeBSD kernel port shipped a GNU userland. (clarification: Debian ships its own `which`, which is not GNU `which` but is meaningfully close enough in behaviour that it's for the most part irrelevant and the fix, in any case, for being too nonstandard would be "ship GNU `which`", not "suddenly care about POSIX in this one case")

In practice, there is only one meaningful `which` on Debian, with clear semantics, and no possibility of confusion over behaviour.

Which is the reason for bringing up systemd. POSIX doesn't cover init, but it does cover many other system calls and behaviours that systemd explicitly rejects in favor of treating the behaviour of the specific Linuxisms it's built around as a de facto standard.

If Debian is fine with its init system being based on de facto standard, POSIX-incompatible Linuxisms, there is no logical reason for it to oppose treating the GNU userland as a similar de facto standard regardless of what the sclerotic POSIX standard says.

"Don't use `which` if your goal is to write a shell script portable beyond your specific Unix, because it has non standard behaviour" is fine advice, but "the Debian project must remove `which` because somebody might accidentally rely on its non-standardized behaviour in a script they also want to run on Illumos" is utterly daft given the hundreds if not thousands of other ways a Debian system goes beyond POSIX.

Re:Which is not Posix by jabl on Monday November 01, 2021 @02:52PM (#29071180)
> GNU `which` is the de facto standard on Linux

Well, no, even on Linux there's no de facto standard. Fedora/RHEL use GNU which, but Debian-derived distros use the debianutils which, which is not the same as GNU which.

> POSIX doesn't cover init, but it does cover many other system calls and behaviours that systemd explicitly rejects

Interesting. Can you be a bit more specific? What in POSIX does systemd explicitly reject? And might there be a reason for that?

Re:Which is not Posix by msbarnett on Monday November 01, 2021 @03:10PM (#29071476)
> Interesting. Can you be a bit more specific? What in POSIX does systemd explicitly reject? And might there be a reason for that?

The project specifically rejects "caring about POSIX" in its entirety. Poettering has discussed this at length[1].

I'm not criticizing systemd here, I'm merely pointing out that Debian is already perfectly fine with shipping non-portable, aPOSIX or even anti-POSIX software by default (which I think is fine), and that the sudden pearl-clutching around `which` not being POSIX is completely inconsistent with many other decisions the project makes and has made.

[1]: https://archive.fosdem.org/2011/interview/lennart-poettering...

"In fact, the way I see things the Linux API has been taking the role of the POSIX API and Linux is the focal point of all Free Software development. Due to that I can only recommend developers to try to hack with only Linux in mind and experience the freedom and the opportunities this offers you. So, get yourself a copy of The Linux Programming Interface, ignore everything it says about POSIX compatibility and hack away your amazing Linux software. It's quite relieving!"

The interview notes various POSIX-incompatibilities as they existed in 2011. They have grown enormously since. It surfaces in userland in a huge number of ways, and *BSD ports maintainers have noted that it's increasingly hard to port any number of things due to the systemd-isms (which now extend to logging, cron, home directories, and many other core functionality replacements) they're baking in.

Again, this is not intended to criticize systemd, but this is precisely the sort of effect that people are hand-wringing about wrt `which` in bash scripts, but nobody is insisting that systemd needs be removed from Debian for having similar POSIX portability impacts. POSIX compatibility has simply never been a meaningful goal of Debian

Re:Which is not Posix by orhmeh09 on Monday November 01, 2021 @04:14PM (#29072402)
If Debian is perfectly fine with anti-POSIX, why go to the effort of making and switching to dash over bash? One of the impetuses for that project was bash’s inability to confirm to posix even when launched in posix mode. What’s that about?
Re:Which is not Posix by mjw1007 on Monday November 01, 2021 @05:16PM (#29073212)
As I understand it, the main motivations were speed and memory footprint. Might not matter too much on a desktop, but people also use Debian for smaller things like Freedombox.
Re:Which is not Posix by jbovlaste on Monday November 01, 2021 @04:56PM (#29073003)
Ubuntu made the switch to dash back in 2006 to decrease boot times, as dash is much faster than bash. This was upstreamed to Debian. POSIX compatibility made the transition easier (as most scripts were made to run on many Unix systems, not just Linux), but was not the motivation for the switch.

https://wiki.ubuntu.com/DashAsBinSh

Re:Which is not Posix by effie on Monday November 01, 2021 @06:57PM (#29074383)
Well Debian isn't some BDFL's project, different authors have different visions that sometimes don't agree with each other. With dash, the original advantages put forward were minimalism, higher speed, and POSIX compliance [1]. But that was a long time ago and when systemd came, the preference for dash may have changed for many Debian authors and maybe dash is just kept in Debian as a token of the past accomplishments.

[1] http://gondor.apana.org.au/~herbert/dash/

Re:Which is not Posix by marcosdumay on Monday November 01, 2021 @05:19PM (#29073259)
The main reason stated at the time was that dash was a much faster executable that would improve the performance on boot and all background tasks.
Re:Which is not Posix by bachmeier on Monday November 01, 2021 @04:04PM (#29072282)
> Well, no, even on Linux there's no de facto standard. Fedora/RHEL use GNU which, but Debian-derived distros use the debianutils which, which is not the same as GNU which.

Honest question, is any of this relevant? It's a mystery to me why anyone would care as long as it gets the job done. Anyone wanting something else can go ahead and use it. Put differently: it would make no difference to anyone currently using command -v. If the Debian devs have a time machine, they can go back to the start and change the course of history. Otherwise none of the discussion around this issue makes sense.

Re:Which is not Posix by chasil on Monday November 01, 2021 @03:11PM (#29071497)
The one that comes to my mind is crontab, [which can be] replaced by timer units.

These are all the POSIX standardized commands:

https://pubs.opengroup.org/onlinepubs/9699919799/utilities/

It's also interesting that POSIX specified a job queue environment that nobody seems to use (entry with the qsub command), separate from the simple job system that originated in Bill Joy's C shell. The systemd oneshot service modifier comes to mind as an alternative to qsub.

Re:Which is not Posix by orhmeh09 on Monday November 01, 2021 @04:16PM (#29072441)
I use qsub daily with sun grid engine. Other derivatives of grid engine and I believe SLURM also implement qsub.
Re:Which is not Posix by tannhaeuser on Monday November 01, 2021 @05:09PM (#29073138)
FYI: LSB [1] is/was the ISO-sanctioned Linux standardization effort, on top of and beyond POSIX/SUS. But it hasn't caught up with recent major changes such as systemd, namespaces/Docker, io_uring, etc. and nobody really seems to care anymore.

[1]: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Linux_Standard_Base

Re:Which is not Posix by jfrunyon on Monday November 01, 2021 @05:33PM (#29073421)
> incompatible

How?