Re:Solar-panel "trees" really are inferior
by nikster on Saturday August 20, 2011 @10:46AM
(#2906743)
The idea had apparently been around for a while, since 2008 or so, there were other, similar studies. I don't know if they were similarly flawed or not though.
I also would not completely dismiss the premise - trees are probably very good at converting solar energy.
And to add to that, I don't buy the counter argument that a tree arrangement can't be better than a flat panel - why not? The sun moves around so the flat panel might be optimal at one point in the day, but will certainly be sub-optimal at other times. This isn't a clear cut argument at all. There are many variables in play. Cloud cover; seasons; etc. Keep in mind the experiment was done in a cold climate.
Re:Solar-panel "trees" really are inferior
by daemonize on Saturday August 20, 2011 @11:23AM
(#2906818)
I would imaginr that the flat panel could be hooked to a servo and a control loop be used to optimize poiting attitude in real time to compensate for the sun's natural cycle.
Re:Solar-panel "trees" really are inferior
by shabble on Saturday August 20, 2011 @12:57PM
(#2907040)
This is already extremely common, with significant efficiency gains. As ever, the downside is added complexity and cost.
See https://secure.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/wiki/Solar_tracker
I would want to encourage young people as much as possible, it's just that some of the things you heard about are only considered impressive when those doing the story have factored age into it. If the person was say 30 it wouldn't even be a story.